NVQ Level 6 Diploma in OSH
Identify, assess and control health and safety risks — ProQual Level 6 NVQ Unit 5
Demonstrate the whole risk-control cycle: investigate work, judge exposure, consult people, choose controls and verify implementation.
Understanding Identify, assess and control health and safety risks — ProQual Level 6 NVQ Unit 5
Demonstrate the whole risk-control cycle: investigate work, judge exposure, consult people, choose controls and verify implementation.
Why this matters at work
A useful assessment explains the mechanism between hazard and harm. Mechanical energy can crush, cut, entangle, trap or eject. Gravity can cause a fall or falling object. Electricity can pass current through the body or initiate fire and arc effects. Thermal energy can burn or create heat strain. Pressure can rupture containment or inject material. Noise and vibration can damage hearing, nerves, circulation and musculoskeletal structures over time.
For each credible scenario, state the initiating condition, exposure route, who is affected, harm mechanism, potential injury or illness and the barriers that already exist. Test whether the barrier is independent, available in the relevant state, maintained and likely to be used under foreseeable pressure. Residual risk should reflect actual installed and verified controls, not a proposed improvement. A numerical matrix may help triage; it must not reduce the seriousness of a plausible fatality by optimistic likelihood labels unsupported by evidence.
How organisations manage this in practice
Controls normally begin with removal of the need to enter danger, safer design, fixed guarding, physical segregation, fall prevention, mechanical handling, isolation and verified zero-energy state. Inspection, maintenance, permits, traffic rules, information and competence support engineered controls. PPE is selected for residual hazards and must not substitute for guarding or fall prevention where higher-order controls are practicable.
Consultation should expose practical conflicts. Ask operators and maintainers whether an enclosure can be opened without bypassing an interlock, whether a lifting aid fits the real aisle, whether a delivery route forces pedestrians into vehicle traffic, and whether emergency equipment can be reached. Record which feedback changed the design, what could not be adopted and why. Before implementation, assign resources, procurement, training, supervision, maintenance, inspection and action ownership rather than listing ideal controls without a delivery route.
Review controls to make sure they work. HSE advises review when controls may no longer be effective, workplace changes create new risk, workers identify problems, or accidents or near misses occur. Other triggers include ill-health trends, complaints, monitoring results, maintenance defects, enforcement, new guidance, equipment changes and evidence that assumptions were wrong.
How can I demonstrate my workplace practice for unit 5?
Demonstrate the whole risk-control cycle: investigate work, judge exposure, consult people, choose controls and verify implementation. Unit reference: Y/616/9535.
Plan a real activity with your assessor and identify the decisions, work products and witnesses that can show your own competence. The following suggestions are options to adapt, not mandatory document lists or model answers to submit.
What practical work should the evidence demonstrate?
Keep hazard, exposure, risk and control separate in your explanation. Identify the source of harm, describe how people encounter it and judge what existing controls actually achieve. A numerical matrix can support prioritisation but does not replace competent analysis or hazard-specific assessment.
Compare controls in a sensible order: can the hazardous activity be removed or redesigned, can exposure be prevented by engineering, and what supporting arrangements remain necessary? Explain residual risk, maintenance, competence and foreseeable abnormal work such as cleaning or breakdown recovery.
Measurements are only meaningful with suitable methods, representative conditions and competent interpretation. Record limits in your own experience and use specialist support where needed. A consultant's report is supporting evidence; your portfolio must still show how you specified, interpreted and acted on it.
What workplace project could I use to develop evidence?
Employees manually clear a blocked packaging line. Observe the task with those who do it, including foreseeable upset conditions, review isolation arrangements and assess the people exposed. Compare engineering and task-design options, obtain the resources needed and verify the revised method in use. Explain the limits of your expertise and any specialist input.
This is an illustrative project, not an account to copy or a required template. Choose an activity you genuinely undertook and agree its scope with your assessor. If you advise rather than hold operational authority, evidence the recommendations, consultation and follow-up that were yours, alongside the decisions taken by authorised colleagues.
One project may cover only part of the unit. Check the full criterion map and plan additional genuine activities, knowledge evidence and professional development wherever the project leaves gaps. Do not treat an illustrative sample as proof of whole-unit coverage.
Build an evidence trail
- Explain the workplace, your role, the starting problem and the limits of your authority. Identify the activity dates and who can confirm your contribution.
- Keep the information you used, the options considered and your reasons for the decision. Identify specialist advice and distinguish what you knew from what you assumed.
- Show consultation and implementation: who agreed the action, what you personally delivered and how resources, ownership and deadlines were arranged.
- Include a follow-up check and an honest account of the result. Explain remaining gaps and what you would change; do not create outcomes that did not occur.
Prepare the evidence index
For unit 5, give each item an identifier, date, version, author, your contribution, relevant criterion references and exact page or paragraph locations. Record how authenticity can be checked. Cross-reference a genuinely relevant item to other units rather than creating duplicate copies, but explain separately how it supports each criterion.
Obtain permission before sharing workplace records. Redact names, commercial details and health information while preserving enough context for assessment. Arrange secure assessor access or an authenticated witness account where copying is inappropriate. Never upload identifiable incident or medical records to a public page or an unapproved AI tool.
How can I plan workplace evidence against each criterion?
The reference numbers below help you plan work and locate evidence. The activities, evidence suggestions and questions are original SHARE learning guidance, not the official criterion wording or a promise of acceptance. Use your assessor-issued assessment plan and the awarding-body specification for the exact requirements.
Open the ProQual qualification specificationOutcome 1: Gather reliable evidence about the work
1.1 · Plan an inspection around the activity, relevant records, people to consult and your own safe access.
Evidence you could select
Inspection plan and scope. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Why did you choose this scope? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
1.2 · Inspect actual conditions and record hazards with enough context to explain who could be harmed.
Evidence you could select
Dated findings and annotated photographs. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What made the finding significant? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
1.3 · Watch how the job is performed across routine and upset conditions instead of relying on the written method.
Evidence you could select
Task observation and worker account. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Where did practice differ from the procedure? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
1.4 · Review a proposed process or equipment change before it enters service, including installation and maintenance interfaces.
Evidence you could select
Change review and pre-start findings. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What risk would otherwise be introduced? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
1.5 · Select suitable measurement support within your competence, checking calibration and conditions or commissioning a specialist.
Evidence you could select
Measurement plan and equipment records. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What limits apply to your results? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
1.6 · Keep findings traceable to location, activity, date, affected people and follow-up action.
Evidence you could select
Inspection register and action links. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Could someone else act on your record? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
Outcome 2: Turn findings into a defensible assessment
2.1 · Compare available assessment approaches and choose one that fits the hazard rather than forcing every risk into a matrix.
Evidence you could select
Method selection note. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Why is this method suitable? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
2.2 · Complete an assessment using field evidence, consultation and credible supporting information.
Evidence you could select
Assessment and contribution record. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What evidence supports the conclusions? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
2.3 · Use suitable exposure information or competent measurement support; document sampling conditions and uncertainty.
Evidence you could select
Exposure report and interpretation. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
How representative is the evidence? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
2.4 · Consider employees, contractors, visitors and people with different needs when judging likely harm.
Evidence you could select
People-at-risk analysis. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Who could be missed by a typical-worker assumption? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
2.5 · Explain the order of action using severity, likelihood, exposure and control weakness rather than a score alone.
Evidence you could select
Prioritised action plan. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Which urgent action could not wait? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
2.6 · Record assumptions, existing controls, decisions, owners and review triggers in a retrievable assessment.
Evidence you could select
Controlled assessment register. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What would trigger reassessment? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
Outcome 3: Implement controls rather than propose them only
3.1 · Test whether current controls work during normal and abnormal tasks; identify unsupported assumptions.
Evidence you could select
Control-effectiveness review. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Where could the barrier fail? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.2 · Map the proposed control approach to relevant requirements and the organisation's operating arrangements.
Evidence you could select
Requirement and control comparison. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What is the minimum acceptable protection? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.3 · Compare safer task design and engineering options before relying on instructions or protective equipment.
Evidence you could select
Options appraisal. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Why did you reject the alternatives? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.4 · Specify competent people, equipment, downtime and maintenance needed to make the chosen control work.
Evidence you could select
Resourced implementation proposal. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What happens if a resource is unavailable? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.5 · Compare lifecycle costs and benefits with stated assumptions; never use cost savings to excuse an unmet duty.
Evidence you could select
Cost comparison and decision rationale. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Which uncertainty most affects your estimate? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.6 · Consult operational managers, workers and representatives on usability before the final control decision.
Evidence you could select
Consultation notes and responses. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
How did consultation change the design? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.7 · Sequence urgent safeguards, permanent changes and verification with accountable owners.
Evidence you could select
Implementation schedule and progress evidence. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
How did you control risk during transition? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.8 · Arrange practical learning and competence checks for people using or maintaining the control.
Evidence you could select
Briefing and performance checks. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
How do you know they can use it safely? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
3.9 · Retain the installed-control specification, authorisation and field verification alongside the risk assessment.
Evidence you could select
Control record and close-out evidence. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Can the next reviewer trace what changed? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
Outcome 4: Defend the reasoning behind the assessment
4.1 · Compare observation, records, consultation and specialist surveys for your selected hazard.
Evidence you could select
Method appraisal and limitations. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Which method would reveal a hidden exposure? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.2 · Explain how severity, likelihood, exposure and uncertainty shaped your decision; challenge spurious precision.
Evidence you could select
Worked assessment reasoning. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What can the score not tell you? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.3 · Discuss applicable duties, tolerability and record quality using the facts of your case and its jurisdiction.
Evidence you could select
Requirements reflection. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
How did external expectations affect the decision? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.4 · Explain how individual controls interact and what happens if a critical barrier fails.
Evidence you could select
Barrier diagram and reflective account. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Is there a single point of failure? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.5 · Defend your selected method using risk reduction, practicality and verified performance evidence.
Evidence you could select
Control justification and field results. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
What evidence would make you change it? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.6 · Consider new guidance, suppliers, available technology and workforce needs when comparing controls.
Evidence you could select
External-factor appraisal. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Which factor altered your initial plan? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
4.7 · Compare eliminating the task, engineering changes and administrative protections in a real example.
Evidence you could select
Hierarchy comparison. Keep the relevant extract and explain your personal contribution rather than submitting an unexplained file.
Discuss with your assessor
Why is relying on PPE alone weak here? Refer to a specific decision, the information available at the time and what happened afterwards.
5.1 · Evidence your professional development
Use a learning episode related to this unit: identify a gap in your capability, set a realistic objective, record the activity and explain how you applied the learning. Discuss an ethical decision, an inclusion issue and a contribution to professional discussion. Finish with a dated review of progress and the next priority. A list of courses attended is not a reflective development record.
Evidence options: a competence self-review, dated development plan, reflective CPD entry, an ethical or inclusive-practice example and a record of professional exchange. Cross-reference the same genuine portfolio across units where appropriate, adding a unit-specific reflection.
Which background reading supports this unit?
Use the linked SHARE topics to strengthen your understanding, then explain the decisions you made in your own organisation. Reading alone is not evidence that you performed the work.
What should I check before submitting evidence to my assessor?
Check that the evidence is authentic, relevant to the registered criteria and clear about your own decisions, actions and results. Resolve gaps with your assessor and protect personal or confidential information before submission.
- Performance: show work you actually did, not just what a practitioner ought to do. Explain your contribution to team-produced documents.
- Reasoning: answer explain, analyse, evaluate and justify questions with decisions, alternatives and limitations, not copied definitions.
- Coverage: map every reference to a precise piece of evidence. Discuss gaps early, including missing authority, specialist tasks or no genuine incident or external request.
- Authenticity and sufficiency: ask what observation, questioning or witness evidence the assessor needs. A job title, course certificate or large upload alone is not proof of competence.
- Exercises: label drills and simulated records accurately. Their acceptability depends on the assessment requirements and assessor agreement; never present them as genuine emergencies or incidents.
- Outcome: the assessor decides whether the evidence meets the requirements, subject to centre and awarding-body quality assurance. These learning pages do not award competence or replace assessment.
How to use this page
How can I match the criteria to real workplace activity?
This unit explains how hazards are identified, risks are assessed, controls are selected and safe systems of work are implemented.
This study guide supports Level 6 occupational health and safety practice. It helps learners understand risk assessment and map normal workplace activity into credible portfolio evidence. Use your registered centre’s current unit specification for the actual assessment criteria and evidence rules.
The strongest portfolios do not simply upload documents. They explain why the work was needed, how decisions were made, who was involved, what changed and how the candidate knows the outcome was effective.
Assessment mindset
- Start with the assessment plan and agree which workplace activities can cover each criterion.
- Use records, communications, risk decisions, monitoring outputs and review notes as evidence.
- Add a reflective account explaining your role, judgement, limitations and follow-up.
- Expect assessor questions where a document alone does not prove competence.
Unit theory
How does assessment lead to effective control?
Risk management begins with understanding work as done: tasks, people, equipment, environment, substances, interfaces and change.
Risk assessment should be suitable and sufficient. It should identify foreseeable hazards, who may be harmed, existing controls, further controls and review triggers.
Control selection should follow prevention principles and the hierarchy of control, giving priority to elimination, substitution, engineering controls and safe systems before relying on behaviour or PPE.
For NVQ evidence, the learner should show a complete chain from inspection and hazard identification through assessment, control implementation, communication and monitoring.
Apply the law for the work location. In Great Britain, the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 and Management Regulations 1999 set the general and risk-assessment routes. Northern Ireland uses the separate Health and Safety at Work (Northern Ireland) Order 1978 and Management Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000. The qualification context does not replace a competent assessment of the actual work or local duties.
Use the HSE risk-management steps to identify hazards, assess who may be harmed, control, record and review. For a loading-bay task, compare a separated pedestrian route and vehicle barrier with a warning sign: the physical separation interrupts the collision path, while the sign relies on people noticing and obeying it. Name who verifies the barrier and stop loading if the route is breached. HSE’s hierarchy places elimination and engineering controls ahead of administrative rules and PPE.
Learning narrative
How does this unit apply in real organisations?
Explain hazard, risk, likelihood, severity, exposure, control effectiveness and residual risk.
Connect risk assessment to legal duties, safe systems of work, permits, method statements and management of change.
Show how risk controls are checked and reviewed after incidents, audits or changes in work.
Good NVQ evidence moves from principle to practice: explain the concept, show why it matters in UK occupational health and safety management, describe what good practice looks like, then show how evidence could be produced in different work settings.
The underlying principle
Risk management begins with understanding work as done: tasks, people, equipment, environment, substances, interfaces and change.
Risk assessment should be suitable and sufficient. It should identify foreseeable hazards, who may be harmed, existing controls, further controls and review triggers.
Control selection should follow prevention principles and the hierarchy of control, giving priority to elimination, substitution, engineering controls and safe systems before relying on behaviour or PPE.
For the related management guidance, see HSE: Managing for health and safety (HSG65).
What good evidence can look like
How can portfolio evidence demonstrate competent performance?
Core themes
- Workplace inspection, hazard identification and task observation.
- Risk assessment methods, prioritisation and selection of controls.
- Hierarchy of control, safe systems of work, permits and procedures.
- Monitoring control effectiveness and reviewing after change or incident.
Whole-unit workplace examples
- Workplace inspection leading to risk-control improvement
- Scenario: During an inspection, the practitioner identifies blocked pedestrian routes, poor housekeeping and damaged racking. They assess the risk, agree corrective actions and track completion.
- Criteria connection: This can support criteria on conducting inspections, identifying hazards, assessing risk and implementing control measures.
- Typical evidence: Inspection report, photographs, risk assessment update, action tracker, close-out evidence and communication to supervisors.
- Reviewing a task risk assessment
- Scenario: A new cleaning chemical is introduced. The practitioner reviews the task, checks the safety data sheet, consults workers and updates the COSHH/risk assessment and safe system of work.
- Criteria connection: This can satisfy criteria on assessing health and safety risks, selecting controls and implementing safe systems of work.
- Typical evidence: COSHH assessment, risk assessment, SDS review, revised procedure, training record and worker sign-off.
Criteria study guide
The numbered explanations below are SHARE study aids, not the awarding body's official assessment criteria. Confirm the current criteria, numbering and assessment plan with your registered centre before using them for assessment.
Which principles help me satisfy the criteria in practice?
Use these blocks to plan evidence, prepare reflective accounts and test whether the portfolio shows your own competent contribution.
1. Be able to conduct an inspection of the workplace.
6 criteria in this learning outcome.
Criterion 1.1
Identify the requirements to carry out a health and safety inspection.
Requirements can include referencing guidance like HSG65. You may also need access to previous inspection records, specialist assistance (e.g., a chemist, vet), and specialist equipment (e.g., for dust or noise).
The theory behind this criterion is that proactive monitoring gives assurance before harm occurs. It tests whether standards, controls and behaviours are present and effective.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner turns this requirement into a monitoring standard, dashboard or assurance check that senior managers can use to understand performance.
Evidence may include inspection programme, audit plan, completed checklists, performance dashboard, corrective-action tracker, management report. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 1.2
Inspect the workplace to identify and evaluate hazards.
You can identify hazards through observation, walkabouts, formal or informal inspections, interviews, questioning, and consultation.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 1.3
Evaluate hazards through observation of work activities.
This involves safety walks, audits, inspections, proactive monitoring, and near-miss reports that lead you to evaluate the efficacy of controls that are in place. You should also engage frontline workers to ask for their input on how to make it more efficient and safer.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 1.4
Examine proposed activities to identify and evaluate hazards including: new workplaces, new equipment, new processes, new activities.
Use analysis techniques, studies, assessments, and audits such as HAZID (Hazard Identification) or fire risk assessments. For new equipment, you may need to conduct a PUWER (Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations) assessment and consult manufacturer's guidance.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 1.5
Select and use appropriate measuring equipment.
This could involve using specialised equipment such as dosimeters or gas meters for instant readouts.
The theory behind this criterion is that health and safety management is a structured, evidence-based process that connects legal duties, risk control, people, information and continual improvement.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner sets a clear standard, communicates expectations and checks whether evidence shows the requirement is being met.
Evidence may include procedure, plan, meeting minutes, decision log, implementation record, monitoring evidence. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 1.6
Maintain records of the hazards identified in sufficient detail to meet: statutory requirements, organisational requirements, industry best practice.
Records can include risk assessments, inspection records, meeting minutes, data sheets, and photographs.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
2. Be able to assess risks to health and safety.
6 criteria in this learning outcome.
Criterion 2.1
Select appropriate risk assessment methods.
Methods include observation, consultation, and the use of monitoring equipment.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 2.2
Conduct a risk assessment of the hazards identified.
Hazards can relate to machinery, fumes, vapours, noise, or traffic movement.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 2.3
Select and use instruments or methods to determine the level of exposure affecting: employees, others who may be affected.
Exposure measurement uses a competent sampling strategy and suitable instruments such as gas meters or noise dosimeters. Substance-specific biological monitoring, such as a suitably timed urine or blood test, assesses uptake where the method is appropriate. Audiometry and other health surveillance detect effects or early signs; they do not measure the level of noise or airborne exposure. Agree purpose, timing and interpretation with competent occupational hygiene or health professionals and keep clinical information confidential.
The theory behind this criterion is that health and safety management is a structured, evidence-based process that connects legal duties, risk control, people, information and continual improvement.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner sets a clear standard, communicates expectations and checks whether evidence shows the requirement is being met.
Evidence may include procedure, plan, meeting minutes, decision log, implementation record, monitoring evidence. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 2.4
Determine risks to health and safety of: employees, others who may be affected.
Consider the risks to other people who may be affected, such as nearby residents, visitors, contractors, or trespassers.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 2.5
Prioritise the health and safety risks to: employees, others who may be affected.
Risks can be prioritised based on severity (serious or minor), and whether they are long-term or short-term. You can use a risk matrix or your organisation’s own methods.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 2.6
Maintain records of the risk assessment in sufficient detail to meet: statutory requirements, organisational requirements, industry best practice.
Records should include identified hazards and risks, who may be affected, the extent of the risk, control measures, and review dates.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
3. Be able to implement risk control measures and safe systems of work in the organisation.
9 criteria in this learning outcome.
Criterion 3.1
Critically analyse the existing risk control measures and current systems of work in the organisation.
Evaluation can involve analysing data and records (including accident/incident records), conducting interviews and consultations, and reviewing inspection results against statutory requirements, industry best practice, and the organisation’s own standards.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.2
Identify for consideration the risk control measures required by: statutory requirements, organisational requirements, industry best practice.
Control measures can relate to people, processes, plant, and the environment. You should reference what the law requires, what your organisation’s policy states, and what others in the industry are doing.
The theory behind this criterion is that policy is a formal control framework. It converts legal duties and leadership intent into responsibilities, arrangements and expected behaviours.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner reviews how responsibilities and arrangements are written, compares them with how the work is managed, consults affected managers and proposes a clearer policy position.
Evidence may include policy documents and final approved policy, gap analysis, consultation records, responsibility matrix, briefing and launch evidence, review schedule. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.3
Identify any additional or improved risk control measures that may be needed.
This involves looking at access to specialist people and equipment. Judge effectiveness from field evidence that the control prevents or adequately controls the assessed harm. Meet mandatory requirements and relevant good practice first; any further reasonably practicable decision must address risk reduction and gross disproportion where applicable. Cost analysis alone proves neither physical effectiveness nor legal sufficiency.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.4
Identify the resources required to implement the risk control measures needed.
This includes time, manpower, and additional training or specialist contractor onboarding.
The theory behind this criterion is that competence is the ability to perform safely and reliably in context. It includes knowledge, skill, experience, behaviour and suitable supervision.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to define competence expectations, identify gaps across sites and commission training, coaching or specialist support.
Evidence may include training needs analysis, competence matrix, role profile, training record, authorisation record, evaluation of effectiveness. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.5
Calculate the cost-effectiveness of the risk control measures needed.
Assess the risk reduction against the money, time and trouble of a further measure. Apply required legal controls and relevant good practice; do not reject an additional measure unless the sacrifice is grossly disproportionate to the safety benefit, with the decision justified and recorded.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.6
Consult with managers, employee representatives and employees about risk controls needed.
All risk assessments and controls should be planned, created, implemented, and reviewed by a cross-section of staff to ensure they are inclusive.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.7
Plan the implementation of risk control measures in order of priority.
Prioritise immediate danger, urgent risk reduction and legal requirements first. Then rank discretionary improvements by risk reduction, feasibility and organisational benefit; a project schedule cannot justify continuing unsafe work. This can be done using planning tools like Gantt charts.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.8
Ensure the provision of training for those who need required competences to implement risk control measures.
New controls need to be communicated through education, information, training, and supervision as required by the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act.
The theory behind this criterion is that communication is part of risk control. Information has to be accurate, timely, targeted and checked for understanding.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner designs a communication route for this requirement, decides who needs the information, chooses the channel and checks whether the message has been understood.
Evidence may include communication plan, briefings or alerts, meeting minutes, feedback records, distribution lists, evidence of understanding or action. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 3.9
Maintain records of the control measures in sufficient detail to meet: statutory requirements, organisational requirements, industry best practice.
Records can include signed documents, updated training matrices, and documents that comply with specific legislative requirements, such as those related to asbestos exposure. You should also follow company policy and industry recommendations for record-keeping.
The theory behind this criterion is that controlled records show which measures were specified, implemented, checked and changed, so the organisation can retrieve reliable evidence when needed.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner assigns record owners, identifies applicable retention requirements, controls access to confidential records, tracks versions and tests retrieval across sites.
Evidence may include a records schedule with retention basis, access controls, version history, approved risk assessments, inspection and maintenance records, training records and proof that corrective controls were implemented and reviewed. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
4. Understand how risks are assessed and controls selected.
7 criteria in this learning outcome. Original study paraphrase; verify the registered specification.
Criterion 4.1
Evaluate the methods of identification of health and safety hazards within the organisation including: risk assessment methods, physical resources, instruments and survey methods which may be used to determine the level of exposure to people who may be affected.
Methods include observation, data analysis from accident and incident records, and the use of monitoring equipment. You should also consider who creates and manages risk assessments and whether external resources are needed for specialist analysis.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.2
Evaluate principles of the analysis methods for determining risks.
This involves using risk assessment methods such as LOPA (Layer of Protection Analysis), qualitative, semi-quantitative, and quantitative methods. For a newly designed facility, you might use a HAZID study and then more specific risk assessments for things like fire or traffic management.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.3
Explain external factors influencing the identification of health and safety hazards, including: health and safety statutory requirements, acceptability of risk, quality management requirements for documentation.
External factors include UK and EU legislation, professional body expectations, and customer demands. Risk acceptability depends on legal duties, relevant good practice and whether further reduction is reasonably practicable; a simple cost-benefit balance is insufficient. You should also consider which international and industry standards must be adhered to.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.4
Evaluate the nature and role of health and safety risk control measures within the organisation.
Control measures and their justification are influenced by regulatory requirements, the hierarchy of control, the organisation's priorities, its safety culture, and accident statistics.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.5
Justify health and safety risk control measures, including safe systems of work.
You must be able to justify why certain control measures are sufficient, drawing on applicable legal requirements, relevant good practice, approved codes of practice and verified field performance. Assess further reasonably practicable measures using the applicable risk-reduction test; a simple cost-benefit balance does not establish sufficiency.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.6
Explain external factors influencing health and safety risk control methods.
External factors include regulatory requirements, client demands, and industry best practices.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
Criterion 4.7
Evaluate risk control hierarchies.
You should explain the hierarchy of control and how you have applied it to your organisation’s or your occupational hazards.
The theory behind this criterion is that risk management is a systematic process for understanding hazards, exposure, foreseeable harm and the effectiveness of controls.
Corporate health and safety manager in a multi-site organisation - logistics, retail, utilities or services: In this context, the practitioner uses this requirement to review risk profile, set minimum control standards and require evidence that high-risk activities are controlled consistently.
Evidence may include inspection record, risk assessment, safe system of work, method statement or permit, control implementation evidence, monitoring or review record. Explain your own decisions, involvement and follow-up rather than treating the record alone as proof of competence.
5. Be able to maintain and record professional development.
1 criterion in this learning outcome.
Criterion 5.1
Maintain a personal development portfolio that evaluates competence, reflects on CPD, sets realistic priorities, applies professional ethics, recognises diversity and inclusion, and contributes to professional discussion.
A portfolio is a record of learning and changed judgement, not a list of courses attended. Compare your capability with the demands of this unit, identify a real gap, choose a relevant activity, then explain what you learned and how you tested it in work. Keep evidence of the result and any remaining limitation.
For this unit, connect reflection to a decision about culture, policy, communication, competence or risk control, as appropriate. Record how feedback from workers, managers or a competent peer changed your approach; distinguish your own contribution from the team's work. Protect confidential workplace and personal information.
Evidence may include a dated competence self-review, a prioritised CPD plan, reflective entries, anonymised work products, peer discussion and a later check of changed practice. Agree the registered specification and evidence sufficiency with the assessor.
Using the two criterion routes
These numbered blocks are original study paraphrases. The linked February 2018 ProQual specification is a reference for Unit 5 (Y/616/9535), not proof of current registration rules. Confirm the specification version and assessment plan applicable to your registration with your centre. The earlier criterion-planning blocks and the explanations here support the same evidence trail; use the retained criterion anchors to compare them.
Evidence trail: an observed packaging-line jam leads to abnormal-work assessment, comparison of stronger controls, authorised implementation, a difficult-shift field test and an evidence-index entry explaining the candidate’s own contribution. Redact personal and commercially sensitive records. One project may not cover every criterion.
ProQual: Level 6 qualification specification, February 2018 reference
How can the hierarchy of controls identify and verify stronger controls for conveyor maintenance?
Source basis
Which official sources support this guidance?
Use the instrument for the work location. HSE guidance explains Great Britain practice and can inform technical thinking elsewhere, but it is not Northern Ireland law. These sources support the safety principles on this page; they do not verify a qualification’s current criteria.
| Authority | Official link | Jurisdiction | Decision supported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legislation | Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 | Great Britain | General workplace health and safety duties. |
| Legislation | Management Regulations 1999 | Great Britain | Risk assessment and management arrangements. |
| Legislation | Health and Safety at Work (Northern Ireland) Order 1978 | Northern Ireland | Separate NI general duty route. |
| Legislation | Management Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000 | Northern Ireland | Separate NI risk-assessment route. |
| HSE | Steps needed to manage risk | Great Britain | Identify, assess, control, record and review; point-of-work application. |
| HSE | Hierarchy of controls | Great Britain | Control order and why PPE is the last resort. |
| HSE | HSG65: Managing for health and safety | Great Britain | Management, monitoring and review of controls. |
| HSE | HSG245: Investigating accidents and incidents | Great Britain | Use incident learning to revise the assessment and controls. |
| HSE | INDG417: Leading health and safety at work | Great Britain | Leadership decisions, resources and assurance. |
| HSE | HSG48: Reducing error and influencing behaviour | Great Britain | Human factors when implementing controls. |
| HSE | INDG345: Health and safety training | Great Britain | Task instruction and competence evidence. |