SHARE Knowledge Hub

ACOPs, HSGs and INDG

Approved Codes of Practice (ACOPs), Health and Safety Guidance (HSG) books and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) information document series (INDG) serve different purposes in Great Britain (GB). Start with the applicable law and task, check the current publication and its status, then turn the relevant advice into controls. In Northern Ireland (NI), check the Health and Safety Executive for Northern Ireland (HSENI) approval lists and NI law before using a GB ACOP. HSGs and INDG leaflets are guidance, not a substitute for a risk assessment or safe work.

Updated 2026-10-21Great Britain and Northern IrelandVersion 2.3

Understanding ACOPs, HSGs and INDG

Approved Codes of Practice (ACOPs), Health and Safety Guidance (HSG) books and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) information document series (INDG) serve different purposes in Great Britain (GB). Start with the applicable law and task, check the current publication and its status, then turn the relevant advice into controls. In Northern Ireland (NI), check the Health and Safety Executive for Northern Ireland (HSENI) approval lists and NI law before using a GB ACOP. HSGs and INDG leaflets are guidance, not a substitute for a risk assessment or safe work.

Why this matters at work

Leaders should ask which credible events could cause fatality or serious ill health, what recognised good practice says, which controls are impaired and how the organisation knows. Investment should follow risk rather than the visibility of a topic. When the full solution needs time, set defensible interim restrictions and a restoration plan; do not relabel an unresolved gap as accepted simply because it is expensive.

Active monitoring checks controls before harm occurs. Examples include workplace inspection, observation, maintenance compliance, exposure monitoring, competence sampling and testing of emergency arrangements. The frequency and depth should reflect the risk and rate of change.

How organisations manage this in practice

Connect the control with procurement, maintenance, competence, contractor coordination, supervision and emergency arrangements. Workers should understand the method and be able to use it under real conditions. Verify implementation by observing representative tasks, inspecting physical protection, sampling records and asking users about obstacles and workarounds. Combine active checks with incident and near miss learning. A completed course does not prove task competence and a current procedure does not prove it is workable. Give findings owners and deadlines and check effectiveness after action. Reassess when plant, substances, staffing, work methods or the source changes, and keep enough evidence to explain both the decision and what was actually implemented.

Plan includes leadership commitment, policy, risk profiling and prioritisation. Do includes worker involvement, competence, communication, control of contractors and implementation of precautions. Check includes active monitoring before harm and reactive learning after events. Act includes performance review and learning from evidence.

A small garage or hospitality business can use a proportionate sequence. List the significant activities and people, identify the main law and current HSE starting guidance, walk the workplace with workers, and decide what physical and organisational controls are needed. Assign actions, obtain competent help for vehicle lifts, electricity, gas, asbestos or other technical risks, and keep the records required by law. The owner should see whether controls work during normal and busy periods.

What is the scope and authority of this page?

Use this page to select and apply official safety publications; it does not replace the actual law, current source, manufacturer instructions or competent task assessment.

Workplace risk, not a publication code, drives the decision. First identify Great Britain or Northern Ireland, then the work, people, equipment or substance, binding duty and current official source. If the source gives a general explanation only, obtain the detailed task guidance before authorising high-risk work.

Use the law and an approved Code for its stated jurisdiction and matters; HSGs, INDG leaflets and local procedures are guidance routes with different force. If a source is withdrawn or two sources appear to conflict, pause the affected decision and check the live regulator record.

Select the right source for the actual duty

A useful source register starts with the task and work location. Identify the binding duty, then record whether the supporting publication is an approved Code or ordinary guidance. A publication series or an old identifier does not establish legal status, currentness or Northern Ireland approval.

Keep the exact clause and the resulting workplace decision together. When an alternative method is chosen, record the evidence supporting compliance with the applicable duty. Recheck the record when the law, publication, product or work changes, rather than treating a saved PDF as permanently current.

Guidance incorrectly described as an ACOP

Illustrative example. A refurbishment RAMS cites L153 as an approved Code and uses that description to support a design decision.

Decision. Correct the publication status and test the method against the applicable CDM duties and actual design risks.

Evidence to check. Keep the current law, exact L153 passage, work location and the design decision it informs.

Hold or escalation point. A document label cannot resolve missing design information or prove an NI approval position.

Follow-up. The RAMS owner checks affected source-register entries and briefs the corrected control basis.

View editable Word and Excel documents

What does each role need to do with official guidance?

Workers need usable controls; managers and advisers must establish the applicable source, approve the translation and verify that it works.

Role routes for official guidance
RoleBefore and during workStop or escalateEvidence
Worker or contractorFollow the task control and ask when it conflicts with the work or a source appears wrong.Stop; tell the supervisor; do not improvise around a hazardous unknown.Briefing, permit or task record and the raised query.
SupervisorCheck the current procedure and that people can apply it to the actual place, plant and change.Hold the task when the source, material or method is unresolved.Pre-start check, hold decision and hand-back sign-off.
Manager or dutyholderProvide competent interpretation, resources and approval for departures from an ACOP approach.Escalate an unproven alternative or a conflict with law.Register, risk assessment, decision note and action owner.
Purchaser or maintainerTranslate the task specification into the correct equipment, product instructions and maintenance standard.Do not accept an incompatible or undocumented substitute.Specification, instructions, inspection and change record.
Safety adviser or auditorVerify law, GB/NI scope, current source, ACOP status and effectiveness in real work.Raise a gap when the source cannot be proved current or a control is absent.Source register, sampling notes and close-out evidence.

What is the difference between ACOPs, HSGs and INDG documents?

The main difference is legal status, level of detail and intended audience.

Law, an ACOP and guidance have different roles

Law, an ACOP and guidance have different roles. LEGISLATION: States the legal duties. Apply the instrument and provisions relevant to the actual work. APPROVED CODE: An ACOP has a special legal status for its approved scope. It is not itself the legislation. HSG / INDG: Guidance explains ways to manage risk. Check its content and scope rather than assuming that every guide is an ACOP.
Learning point: Check the publication identity, current edition, scope and jurisdiction before relying on it. The document series alone does not establish legal status.
Read this visual as text
  1. LEGISLATION: States the legal duties. Apply the instrument and provisions relevant to the actual work.
  2. APPROVED CODE: An ACOP has a special legal status for its approved scope. It is not itself the legislation.
  3. HSG / INDG: Guidance explains ways to manage risk. Check its content and scope rather than assuming that every guide is an ACOP.

Read the legal-status comparison together with the task, jurisdiction, exact title and edition. For Northern Ireland, confirm the relevant legal basis and ACOP approval rather than assuming a GB publication transfers unchanged.

UK health and safety law often states the duty in broad terms, such as controlling risk so far as is reasonably practicable, making a suitable and sufficient risk assessment, providing information and training, maintaining equipment or preventing exposure. Official guidance helps dutyholders understand how those duties can be met in practice.

The important mistake is treating every document as if it has the same force. An ACOP is not the same as a short leaflet. A short leaflet is not enough for a complex high-risk task. A technical HSG may be more useful for designing controls than a general awareness guide. An L-series title is not automatically an ACOP: L153 is guidance for CDM 2015, while L113 includes an ACOP and guidance. A robust management system knows which type of document it is using and why.

Comparison of ACOP HSG and INDG document types
Document typeWhat it normally meansHow it should be usedCommon misuse
LegislationAn Act or Regulation that creates a binding legal duty.Use it to identify who owes the duty, what outcome is required and where the legal requirement sits in the legal register.Quoting the law without translating it into practical controls, responsibilities and evidence.
ACOPAn Approved Code of Practice that gives practical advice on complying with particular legal duties and has special legal status.Use it as a recognised compliance benchmark when writing procedures, auditing controls or assessing whether an alternative approach is equally effective.Ignoring the ACOP or treating it as optional guidance without recording how equivalent compliance is achieved.
HSGA Health and Safety Guidance publication that usually gives practical, technical or management guidance on a topic.Use it for detailed control standards, examples, inspection points, management arrangements and training content.Using it as a generic tick list without adapting it to the work, people, environment and risk.
INDGAn HSE information leaflet or brief guide, usually shorter and written for a broader audience.Use it for awareness, worker briefings, small-business introductions and simple explanation of duties.Relying on a brief leaflet as the only source for complex, specialist or high-consequence work.
HSE topic webpageA current web page that explains a topic, signposts duties and links to deeper publications.Use it as a starting point and route map to the correct guidance, ACOPs, forms or enforcement information.Stopping at the web page and missing the more detailed publication or legal duty behind it.

Follow a source into a workplace control

A publication code identifies a source; it does not establish that the source fits the job. Keep the jurisdiction and edition beside the advice so the distinction between law, ACOP and guidance survives a handover.

  1. Identify the task and jurisdiction

    Record the location, activity, substance or equipment and who may be exposed. Establish the applicable legislation for Great Britain or Northern Ireland.

  2. Check the exact source

    Record its title, publication code, edition or update date, relevant section and URL. For an ACOP, check its approval and scope; use the HSENI list when applying a GB publication in Northern Ireland.

  3. Translate the relevant requirement

    Identify the specific duty or control question. An alternative to relevant ACOP provisions must still achieve legal compliance; record the evidence and obtain competent advice where the interpretation is uncertain.

  4. Verify the control in use

    Connect the method to the actual equipment and work conditions. Name the person who checks performance, the evidence required and the change that would trigger another review.

Illustrative source-to-control record: grinding a concrete surface
Record fieldExample
Task and sourceConcrete-surface grinding in a GB workplace; HSE construction-dust guidance, “Scabbling or grinding”, control measures section. Retain the page version or date checked in the task record.
Control questionDoes the chosen on-tool extraction arrangement capture dust from this tool, material and method? Confirm the assessment and manufacturer’s requirements, including any RPE needed for residual exposure.
Workface evidenceCheck the correct shroud, hose and extractor, their condition and the defined operating indication. Observe the actual method and compare it with the assessed arrangement; apparent cleanliness is not an exposure measurement.
Hold and reviewDo not continue the exposed task when a required control fails. Reassess tool, material or method changes before release.

How should I select a current source for the task?

Name the task and jurisdiction, find the binding duty, verify the individual publication's status and edition, then check whether its advice covers the actual risk.

Select the Right Official Source

Two linked parts · 6 questions. Open Part 2 to complete the route.

Select the Right Official Source. Detailed decision map with 6 numbered questions, explicit outcomes, responsible roles and return checks.
Continue to questions 4–6 · Part 2 of 2Select the Right Official Source. Detailed decision map with 6 numbered questions, explicit outcomes, responsible roles and return checks.
Learning point: Source type, edition, jurisdiction, approval scope, duty and task relevance recorded; local assessment can begin. Follow the labelled branches and resolve any hold with the named owner before the relevant checks are repeated.
Read this visual as text
  1. Start: A task, equipment, substance or site condition needs a control standard.
  2. Question 1: Are task, equipment, people and hazard defined? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  3. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 2.
  4. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Resolve what control question the source must answer. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
  5. Question 2: Which jurisdiction governs the work? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  6. Great Britain: Identify applicable GB law and current HSE title information. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
  7. Northern Ireland: Identify NI law and verify HSENI approval where ACOP status is claimed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
  8. Unknown: Hold source reliance until the work location and route are known. HOLD → OWNER RESOLVES BEFORE RESUMING.
  9. Question 3: Are title identity, edition and live status verified? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  10. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 4.
  11. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Resolve withdrawal, amendment or conflicting versions against the official source. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
  12. Question 4: What is the relevant text? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  13. Approved Code: Record the actual approval scope and associated legal duty. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
  14. Guidance: Use as relevant technical advice; do not assign ACOP status. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
  15. Mixed / unclear: Separate Code paragraphs from guidance, or obtain competent clarification. HOLD → OWNER RESOLVES BEFORE RESUMING.
  16. Question 5: Does the advice cover the actual task and conditions? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  17. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
  18. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Find applicable specialist information rather than stretching a familiar title. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
  19. Question 6: Record and apply Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  20. ACTION: Record source, edition, jurisdiction and scope; translate it into task controls and verify in use. OUTCOME → RECORD AND HAND OVER.
  21. Outcome: Source type, edition, jurisdiction, approval scope, duty and task relevance recorded; local assessment can begin.
  22. Stop and escalation boundary: Stop the source decision for a withdrawn or conflicting title, unknown jurisdiction, or a claim of NI approval that cannot be verified.

Work from the law outward. Check the HSE title page for its Code approval statement, publication date and any later amendment; use HSE topic pages and indexes to discover sources. In Northern Ireland, compare the HSENI NI ACOP list and the list of GB Codes approved for NI use. For example, HSENI currently lists L113 against the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1999 and L143 against the Control of Asbestos Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2012. Recheck the live list, edition, associated NI duty and any scope limits for the exact Code before relying on its approval. If a source is withdrawn, a link is broken, or two versions conflict, pause the decision and obtain competent advice.

Record the route you actually verified. Keep the final official destination after any redirect, page title, edition or update, jurisdiction, access date and the claim it informed. A regulator bot challenge, CAPTCHA or rate limit is an automated-access limitation: record it and obtain a later human or permitted check, but do not call the official URL broken or claim that its full content was verified.

Source selection and status test
QuestionCheckDecision record
Where and what is the work?Record GB or NI, task, site, people, equipment, materials and change conditions.Task and jurisdiction in the assessment.
Which duty is binding?Open the current official Act or regulation for that jurisdiction.Provision and dutyholder recorded.
Is the publication an approved Code?Read the individual title and approval statement; check HSENI approval for NI.ACOP, guidance or mixed publication clearly labelled.
Is the copy current?Check edition, amendment, withdrawal and live regulator page.Source URL, date checked, owner and change trigger.
Does it fit the real work?Compare conditions and manufacturer instructions; check specialist constraints.Local control, approver, hold point and verification.

How should a workplace use ACOPs, HSGs and INDG documents?

A workplace should use official guidance as a bridge between legal duties and real work, not as decorative paperwork.

Take the source to the workface

Illustrative UK workplace scene. A source becomes useful when its requirements are translated into a task control and checked in use. A publication on a shelf is not evidence that the work is controlled.
Learning point: A source becomes useful when its requirements are translated into a task control and checked in use. A publication on a shelf is not evidence that the work is controlled.
Read this visual as text
  1. A source becomes useful when its requirements are translated into a task control and checked in use. A publication on a shelf is not evidence that the work is controlled.
  2. CURRENT SOURCE
  3. TASK CONTROL
  4. FIELD VERIFICATION

Illustrative workface briefing. The source-to-control record makes the document title, applicable section, task decision and evidence visible; a tablet or briefing photograph alone does not demonstrate compliance.

The right sequence is simple: identify the activity, identify the law, find the current official guidance, decide what applies to the work, translate it into local arrangements, then check whether those arrangements are working. A small office using display screen equipment will need a different level of detail from a chemical warehouse, construction project, workshop, leisure venue or fuel storage site.

Good use also means controlling document currency. HSE guidance can be amended, withdrawn or replaced. A printed PDF in a folder may no longer be current. The legal register should therefore record the source, version, owner, review date, affected procedures and any decision made where the organisation uses a different but equivalent control method.

Practical workflow for applying official guidance
StepWhat to doOutput or evidence
1. Define the workDescribe the activity, people affected, substances, equipment, environment, contractors and foreseeable abnormal situations.Scope note, task inventory or risk profile.
2. Identify the dutyCheck which Act, Regulation or approved requirement applies before selecting guidance.Legal register entry linked to the topic or task.
3. Select authoritative guidanceUse HSE topic pages, legal reference lists, ACOPs, HSGs and INDG documents rather than generic search results.Source list with current URLs and publication references.
4. Interpret relevanceDecide which parts apply, which are not relevant and whether specialist advice is needed.Competent review note or procedure change record.
5. Translate into controlsTurn guidance into risk assessments, procedures, equipment standards, inspection checks, training and supervision.Approved procedure, RAMS, checklist, training material or inspection regime.
6. Verify in practiceCheck that people, equipment, contractors and records match the intended standard.Inspection, audit, observation, exposure monitoring or management review evidence.
7. Learn and updateReview after legal change, incidents, near misses, enforcement, audit findings, complaints or new HSE guidance.Action log, document review and lessons-learned record.

How does source selection change real workplace decisions?

The right document changes the next safe action only when its status, jurisdiction and task scope are confirmed.

One machine, different source roles

One machine, different source roles. A realistic HD engineering-workplace scene shows two people comparing a document beside a stationary guarded machine, its access door, interlock and control cabinet. A parallel native comparison identifies three different source roles: an applicable approved Code with its special status for the relevant approved scope, technical HSG guidance, and a brief INDG introduction. Current HSE publication records provide L22, HSG129 and INDG291 as examples; no pictured page is claimed to be a readable or verified copy of those publications. The roles are not stages or an invented legal hierarchy. A separate complete four-part connection below the image runs from confirming the law and task, through source status and scope, to equipment-specific application and recorded verification. The actual machinery duty, operating mode, instructions, approval, jurisdiction and workface evidence still need checking. The closed guard and document do not demonstrate compliance or working safeguards.
Law, approved Codes, technical guidance and brief introductions have different roles; verify the actual source and its fit to the machine task.
Full written explanation

A realistic HD engineering-workplace scene shows two people comparing a document beside a stationary guarded machine, its access door, interlock and control cabinet. A parallel native comparison identifies three different source roles: an applicable approved Code with its special status for the relevant approved scope, technical HSG guidance, and a brief INDG introduction. Current HSE publication records provide L22, HSG129 and INDG291 as examples; no pictured page is claimed to be a readable or verified copy of those publications. The roles are not stages or an invented legal hierarchy. A separate complete four-part connection below the image runs from confirming the law and task, through source status and scope, to equipment-specific application and recorded verification. The actual machinery duty, operating mode, instructions, approval, jurisdiction and workface evidence still need checking. The closed guard and document do not demonstrate compliance or working safeguards. Applicable legal duty: Confirm the nation, activity and people before selecting the legal route. Relevant supporting material: An ACOP, technical guide and introductory leaflet have different status and scope. Task-specific decision: The responsible person must establish how the actual arrangements meet the applicable duty.

First confirm the actual duty and jurisdiction; the publication’s stated status and scope support the machine-specific decision.

  1. ACOP · approved scope. For a relevant GB HSE-approved Code, confirm the approved provisions. L22 contains ACOP and guidance; it is not the legislation. An alternative still has to comply with the law.
  2. HSG · technical guidance. HSG129 offers engineering-workshop guidance. Check the actual task, current applicability and edition. An HSG title does not itself give the guide ACOP status.
  3. INDG · brief introduction. INDG291 introduces work-equipment requirements and key issues. The brief leaflet does not supply every machine-specific control, instruction or technical decision.

Change the pathway

  • ACOP status. A relevant approved Code has special evidential status; confirm its actual approval and jurisdiction.
  • HSG technical guidance. Use applicable technical detail, scope and current edition; guidance is not itself an ACOP.
  • INDG introduction. Use a concise introduction to find the right issues, not as a complete method for every task.

Evidence check: HSE guidance, an approved Code and law are not interchangeable. Confirm the status of the actual publication.

Follow the complete jurisdiction, source-status, task-control and verification connection

Primary references: HSE legal status of guidance and ACOPs · HSE L22 publication record: ACOP and guidance · HSE HSG129 publication record: engineering workshops · HSE INDG291 publication record: brief work-equipment guide · HSE L-series index: check each publication’s stated status · HSE chasing-concrete task controls

Open the complete HD image (new tab)Download image

Follow the complete jurisdiction, source-status, task-control and verification connection

Primary references: HSE legal status of guidance and ACOPs · HSE L22 publication record: ACOP and guidance · HSE HSG129 publication record: engineering workshops · HSE INDG291 publication record: brief work-equipment guide · HSE L-series index: check each publication’s stated status · HSE chasing-concrete task controls

A contractor’s document label is not its legal status

A contractor’s document label is not its legal status. A realistic HD inactive British refurbishment scene shows an intact masonry wall, guarded wall chaser, connected extraction hose/unit and surface containment option while two professionals review a drawing. Native numbered explanations distinguish identifying the actual task and legal route, verifying the publisher’s stated source status and scope rather than a contractor’s label, and testing how the proposed method addresses avoidance, dust controls, required RPE and machine instructions. The same complete source-to-control reasoning transfers from the engineering example without giving an HSG, INDG, L-series filename or method statement ACOP status. The scene establishes no exposure, capture performance, product rating, legal compliance or work permission. Original GB/NI source checks, relevant Code approval questions, retained reasoning and competent review holds remain in the complete source and written alternative; no NI approval decision or new legal duty is created.
A method statement must connect the correct duty and current source to verified workface controls; its label or signature does not establish compliance.
Full written explanation

A realistic HD inactive British refurbishment scene shows an intact masonry wall, guarded wall chaser, connected extraction hose/unit and surface containment option while two professionals review a drawing. Native numbered explanations distinguish identifying the actual task and legal route, verifying the publisher’s stated source status and scope rather than a contractor’s label, and testing how the proposed method addresses avoidance, dust controls, required RPE and machine instructions. The same complete source-to-control reasoning transfers from the engineering example without giving an HSG, INDG, L-series filename or method statement ACOP status. The scene establishes no exposure, capture performance, product rating, legal compliance or work permission. Original GB/NI source checks, relevant Code approval questions, retained reasoning and competent review holds remain in the complete source and written alternative; no NI approval decision or new legal duty is created.

Refurbishment example: an inactive concrete-chasing task connects source checks to the actual equipment, dust controls and work method.

  1. Confirm the jurisdiction. Identify the actual GB or NI duty and work activity; do not assume one publication settles both.
  2. Check the document status. Use the publisher’s current title, edition and stated legal status, rather than the filename or a contractor label.
  3. Apply it to the task. Compare scope, site conditions, equipment instructions and competent technical advice.
  4. Retain the reasoning. Record the duty, supporting source and actual work evidence; resolve gaps before the responsible release decision.

When the evidence does not fit: An unverified source, wrong jurisdiction or misdescribed ACOP must be corrected; do not use it as evidence that the work method is acceptable.

Who acts: Dutyholder and task planner, supported by competent technical or legal advice where necessary.

Changed workplace

Engineering machinery: Select applicable technical guidance and the machine instructions for the actual operation.

Contractor refurbishment: Check the legal route and source status: a method statement cannot turn ordinary guidance into an ACOP.

Evidence check: HSE guidance, an approved Code and law are not interchangeable. Confirm the status of the actual publication.

Follow the complete jurisdiction, source-status, task-control and verification connection

Primary references: HSE legal status of guidance and ACOPs · HSE L22 publication record: ACOP and guidance · HSE HSG129 publication record: engineering workshops · HSE INDG291 publication record: brief work-equipment guide · HSE L-series index: check each publication’s stated status · HSE chasing-concrete task controls

Open the complete HD image (new tab)Download image

Follow the complete jurisdiction, source-status, task-control and verification connection

Primary references: HSE legal status of guidance and ACOPs · HSE L22 publication record: ACOP and guidance · HSE HSG129 publication record: engineering workshops · HSE INDG291 publication record: brief work-equipment guide · HSE L-series index: check each publication’s stated status · HSE chasing-concrete task controls

These are decision examples, not substitute method statements. Apply the actual regulation, approved Code or guidance and product instructions to the site before release.

Northern Ireland refurbishment with suspect asbestos

Task, material and setting: A contractor is about to disturb old insulation in a Northern Ireland school. Fibres may be released if the material contains asbestos.

People and prerequisites: Contractors, occupants and other site workers may be affected. The facilities manager needs building records, a competent survey and the correct NI asbestos duty before planning disturbance.

Before: The facilities manager checks the survey and work plan. HSENI lists L143 for use with NI asbestos regulations; confirm its current approval and whether the planned work is in scope.

During: The principal contractor briefs the team, controls access and verifies the agreed plan and competence before any disturbance.

Hold or stop: Stop if material identity, survey or competent plan is missing, or if suspect material is damaged. Use the site asbestos response route.

Completion and hand-back: The responsible manager accepts clearance and the controlled area before it reopens.

Evidence: Keep the survey, applicable NI legal route, source edition, competent plan, briefing and clearance or hand-back record.

Contractor cites a non-existent CDM 2015 ACOP

Task, material and setting: A contractor submits RAMS for refurbishment work in Great Britain and calls L153 a CDM 2015 ACOP. Other trades and occupants could be exposed if the proposed sequence is wrong.

People and prerequisites: The principal contractor, supervisor, workers and affected occupants need the actual site method. Confirm the GB Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 and the current L153 guidance.

Before: The principal contractor identifies that L153 is guidance, corrects the citation and checks the task method, interfaces and site information against current duties.

During: The supervisor briefs contractors, checks segregation and observes whether the agreed controls work during the changed task.

Hold or stop: Do not accept the RAMS or start work while the source is misdescribed or the method does not address the actual task and adjacent people.

Completion and hand-back: The principal contractor releases work only after the revised method and coordination are demonstrated, then checks it after change.

Evidence: Retain the corrected source, revised RAMS, briefing, release decision and field-verification record.

Operational guidance decisions
Situation and peopleBefore and during decisionHold or stopCompletion and evidence
Routine lifting-equipment planning; operators, slingers and nearby workersConfirm equipment, load, lifting plan, operator competence and local procedure; L113 is listed by HSENI for the Lifting Operations and Lifting Equipment Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1999. Recheck current approval and scope, then observe the setup before the lift.Hold the lift if equipment, plan, competent people or exclusion controls are unproven, or the publication is applied outside its scope.Record the plan, equipment checks, authorisation, source version and supervisor follow-up.
Non-routine refurbishment with suspect asbestos; contractors and occupantsUse building information and competent asbestos advice before disturbance; L143 is listed by HSENI for the Control of Asbestos Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2012. Recheck current approval and scope against the NI duty before work.Stop disturbance if material identity or survey information is missing; use the local asbestos emergency arrangement if material is damaged.Retain survey, plan, competent approval, briefing and clearance or hand-back evidence.
Unknown cleaning chemical delivered to a workshop; purchaser, cleaner and nearby staffQuarantine pending identification, supplier information, current safety data and the applicable COSHH route; compare ventilation, handling and storage needs.Do not use or decant an unidentified product or rely on a generic leaflet alone.Record product identity, supplier instructions, assessment, substitution choice and release approval.
Contractor RAMS cites a CDM 2015 ACOP; principal contractor and site teamCheck GB CDM 2015 and current L153 guidance or NI law as appropriate; compare the task method and site conditions.Hold acceptance where the claim of an ACOP is wrong or controls do not address current conditions.Record corrected source, revised RAMS, coordination briefing and authorised start.
New equipment proposed as an alternative to an ACOP method; manager and maintainerCheck the precise approved paragraph, underlying law, manufacturer instructions, relevant performance and competent evidence of alternative compliance.Do not approve on cost, similarity or supplier claim alone; escalate unresolved equivalence.Record comparison, approver, risk decision, commissioning and performance review.
Incident exposes obsolete guidance during a changed task; all site workersProtect people and use emergency response first; preserve the old procedure and source record, then assess similar exposed work.Stop comparable work until interim controls and competent revision are agreed.Record event, affected documents, worker communication, revised controls and effectiveness check.

What checks are needed before, during and after applying guidance?

Treat source choice and control translation as hold points, then verify the control where work actually happens.

Before during and after guidance checks
StageCheckStop or escalateRecord
Before selectionConfirm work, location, people, law, document type, edition and NI approval if relevant.Missing identity, obsolete source or wrong jurisdiction.Source register and task assessment.
Before releaseCompetent owner maps advice to controls, resources, supervision and manufacturer instructions.Conflict, unproven ACOP alternative or uncontrolled high-risk task.Approval, procedure and briefing.
During workSupervisor checks conditions, actual behaviour, equipment and changing hazards.Control not working, unknown substance or unexpected exposure.Observation, stop decision and corrective action.
At hand-backConfirm defect or source conflict resolved, controls tested, people updated and owner accepts restart.Unresolved hazard, missing competent sign-off or unverified alternative.Hand-back and verification record.
Later reviewCheck incidents, audits, source updates and worker feedback for effectiveness.Repeat failure or withdrawn guidance.Version history and review action.

What happens when a source conflict appears during dangerous work or an incident?

Stop the affected work, protect life using local emergency arrangements, and have a competent person resolve the source and control conflict before restart.

Changed Source or Unexpected Hazard

Two linked parts · 6 questions. Open Part 2 to complete the route.

Changed Source or Unexpected Hazard. Detailed decision map with 6 numbered questions, explicit outcomes, responsible roles and return checks.
Continue to questions 4–6 · Part 2 of 2Changed Source or Unexpected Hazard. Detailed decision map with 6 numbered questions, explicit outcomes, responsible roles and return checks.
Learning point: People safe, source/version trail retained, procedures and briefings updated, restart authorised, effectiveness scheduled and checked. Follow the labelled branches and resolve any hold with the named owner before the relevant checks are repeated.
Read this visual as text
  1. Start: A source is amended or withdrawn, or work reveals a hazard not covered by the current method.
  2. Question 1: Is anyone in immediate danger? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  3. YES — STOP / REFER: Raise the alarm and use local emergency arrangements before reviewing documents. STOP / REFER → APPROPRIATE RESPONSE.
  4. NO: No such warning is identified; continue the remaining checks. CONTINUE → QUESTION 2.
  5. UNKNOWN — PROTECT FIRST: Protect people and hold the affected work. Obtain the responsible specialist’s assessment; do not assume the warning is absent. HOLD → OWNER RESOLVES BEFORE RESUMING.
  6. Question 2: Pause affected work Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  7. ACTION: Secure the area and identify similar work that may share the outdated assumption. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
  8. Question 3: Is the source or actual hazard change understood? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  9. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 4.
  10. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Compare controlled versions, equipment information and work conditions. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
  11. Question 4: Are interim controls evidenced for the actual risk? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  12. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
  13. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Keep the affected work stopped; obtain competent technical review. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 4 AFTER CORRECTION.
  14. Question 5: Are procedures, briefings and restart authority updated? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  15. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
  16. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Complete controlled changes and communicate limits across shifts and contractors. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
  17. Question 6: Has effectiveness been checked after the authorised restart? Decision owner: Competent task planner / source reviewer.
  18. YES: The required evidence or condition is confirmed. OUTCOME → RECORD AND HAND OVER.
  19. NO / UNKNOWN — HOLD: Reopen weak controls or unsupported source assumptions. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
  20. Outcome: People safe, source/version trail retained, procedures and briefings updated, restart authorised, effectiveness scheduled and checked.
  21. Stop and escalation boundary: Stop for unknown substances, suspected asbestos, contradictory instructions, uncontrolled energy or an unproven ACOP alternative.

A leaflet is not an emergency plan. If there is injury, exposure, release, fire or another immediate danger, raise the alarm, use first aid and emergency services as required, isolate only within competence, and keep people clear. Preserve the task documents, product information and version that workers were actually using. Check the applicable regulator, reporting and sector route separately; an internal source review must not delay emergency care or interfere with external control.

Stop and escalate for an unknown material, suspected asbestos disturbance, incompatible equipment, missing isolation, contradictory instructions, or a withdrawn source. Restart needs a recorded risk decision, effective interim control and authorised hand-back.

How can the hierarchy of controls guide risk controls using ACOPs and HSE guidance?

Guidance only improves safety when it is owned, translated, taught, checked and reviewed.

Many organisations have access to the right HSE documents but still fail to convert them into action. The usual failure is not a lack of documents; it is weak interpretation, poor ownership, outdated procedures, generic training and audits that check whether a file exists instead of whether the control is working.

The control process should be proportionate. A brief INDG may be enough to support a worker awareness briefing, while an ACOP-linked activity may need a controlled procedure, named competent person, audit schedule and formal management review.

Imagine a refurbishment firm choosing how to control concrete-cutting dust. The legal owner first identifies the actual GB or NI duty, then reads the relevant current regulator material for the task rather than treating an INDG leaflet as a law. Avoiding the cut is elimination; using a different construction method is substitution within ERICPD Reduce; on-tool extraction or an assessed wet method is engineering control; an exclusion zone, instruction and supervision are administrative controls; suitable RPE is the residual layer. An ACOP may give an evidential route for its particular regulations, but neither an ACOP nor an HSG/INDG automatically approves a wheel, method or risk assessment. The site manager records the source edition, jurisdiction and the control decision it informed.

The supervisor checks the selected wheel, guard and dust capture before use, observes whether the method works in the actual material, and stops the cut if the capture fails or the method changes. ERICPD Discipline means maintaining the control, reviewing worker feedback and correcting a weak method. The safety adviser samples the work and checks that the legal register still points to the right GB or NI instrument; a source-document update triggers a task review, not an automatic copy-and-paste change to every procedure. The authority of a source and the effectiveness of an installed control are separate questions.

Controls for managing official guidance and document use
Control areaGood practiceEvidence to check
OwnershipAssign an owner for each legal and guidance area, with authority to update procedures and escalate gaps.Legal register owner, document owner and management review minutes.
Document controlRecord the source, publication reference, issue date, review date and where the guidance has been applied internally.Controlled document register and review history.
Competent interpretationUse competent people to decide how guidance applies, especially where work is technical, high-risk or specialist.Competence records, review notes and sign-off.
Procedure translationWrite procedures in workplace language, showing who does what, when, with what equipment and what records.Procedure, RAMS, permits, checklists and briefing records.
Training and briefingGive different levels of training for workers, supervisors, managers and specialists rather than one generic slide deck.Training matrix, attendance records, assessment results and supervisor briefings.
AssuranceAudit whether the guidance has changed behaviour, controls and evidence, not only whether the guidance is filed.Audit findings, inspection evidence, action close-out and effectiveness reviews.

What should a legal and guidance register include?

A useful register links law, official guidance, internal controls, ownership and review triggers.

A legal register should be more than a list of Acts and Regulations. It should tell the business what the duty means, which official guidance explains it, which internal documents rely on it and who checks that the arrangements remain current.

For a mature system, the register also links to the risk register. This prevents a gap where the law is known by the safety team but not reflected in procurement, contractor management, training, maintenance, inspection or project planning.

What training is needed to use ACOPs, HSGs and INDG guidance well?

Training should build from general awareness to competent interpretation and management assurance.

Not everyone needs to read an ACOP from cover to cover, but everyone should understand the standard that affects their work. Workers need clear controls and reporting routes. Supervisors need to know what they are checking. Managers need to know how guidance affects resources, procedures and competence. Advisers need enough technical skill to interpret and apply official sources properly.

Training should also explain acronyms. Terms such as ACOP, HSG, INDG, HSE, RAMS and ISO should not be assumed. A short acronym table or plain-English explanation prevents confusion and helps new learners take part in health and safety discussions.

Training levels for using official health and safety guidance
Role and learningPractice on the actual taskCompetence evidence and recordAssessor and reassessment trigger
Workers and new starters: recognise the rule behind the taskExplain the local control and report when it is absent or unclear.Observed induction or task briefing with a correct stop/report decision.Supervisor checks at induction and after a changed task or control.
Task users: apply a guidance-based procedureDemonstrate the actual equipment, limits, emergency action and records.Practical observation and scoped task authorisation.Competent task assessor checks before independent use and after process or guidance change.
Supervisors and managers: plan and verify workSelect the applicable law and source, brief contractors, observe work and close defects.Reviewed source-to-control decision, field observation and corrective-action record.Competent manager or safety adviser checks after law change, weak observation or incident.
Specialist advisers: interpret and challenge guidanceCompare law, ACOP, guidance and an alternative control within the actual duty and jurisdiction.Written interpretation with source edition, limits and peer-reviewed field evidence.Experienced specialist or legal adviser checks when approval, scope or legal route changes.
Procurement and document controllers: keep sources usableConfirm the current title and approved edition before buying, specifying or replacing a local document.Controlled source register, supplier specification and withdrawal of superseded copies.Competent owner checks at procurement and after a regulator update.

Record the task, demonstrated decision, assessor, limits of authority and any follow-up. Reassess after changed law, process or equipment, a weak field observation or an incident; do not infer a universal certificate or fixed renewal period.

How can ISO 45001 support official guidance management?

ISO 45001 management-system themes can organise the decisions and evidence needed for official guidance management.

The exact current edition and amendments are not verified from an authorised copy on this page. These management-system themes are voluntary unless adopted by contract or organisation policy. They are useful where they add discipline, but should not be forced into every topic. For ACOPs, HSGs and INDG documents, the alignment is genuinely useful because the subject is about legal obligations, documented information, competence, operational control, performance evaluation and improvement.

The table uses management-system themes to organise practical evidence. It does not assert exact ISO clause wording; use the current licensed edition and competent interpretation for a formal audit.

ISO 45001 style clause alignment for official guidance management
Management-system themeHow it can support this topicPractical evidence
Determination of legal requirements and other requirementsCan help the organisation to determine and have access to applicable legal and other requirements.Legal and guidance register with direct links, ownership, review dates and affected internal documents.
CompetenceCan help people to be competent where their work affects health and safety performance.Training matrix showing awareness, supervisor, manager and specialist competence levels.
AwarenessCan help workers to be aware of policy, risks, controls and implications of not conforming.Worker briefings, toolbox talks and plain-English guidance summaries.
Documented informationCan help controlled documents to be available, suitable and protected from unintended use.Document control system, version history and withdrawal of superseded guidance.
Operational planning and controlCan help planned control of processes needed to meet requirements.Procedures, RAMS, permits, inspection regimes and contractor standards based on current guidance.
Monitoring, measurement, analysis and performance evaluationCan help monitoring and evaluation of health and safety performance.Audits checking whether guidance-based controls work in practice.
Incident, nonconformity and corrective actionCan help action after incidents and nonconformities.Lessons learned used to update guidance interpretation, risk assessments and training.

How does this topic support study, competence and professional development?

This topic helps learners move from memorising definitions to explaining how UK health and safety law is applied in practice.

For general health and safety study, learners should be able to distinguish criminal law, regulations, ACOPs, guidance, internal rules and industry standards. They should also be able to explain why an ACOP has more legal significance than a general guidance leaflet and why an employer must still assess the actual workplace risk.

In scenario-based questions, the examiner or assessor may describe a business with outdated procedures, a weak legal register, generic training or poor contractor control. A strong answer explains how official sources should be identified, interpreted, translated into controls, communicated, checked and reviewed.

Study and competence prompts for ACOPs HSGs and INDG
Learner should understandHow to apply it in practiceScenario-based prompt
Difference between law, ACOP and guidanceUse the correct source for the decision being made.A manager says an ACOP is optional. Explain what is wrong with that statement.
Legal status of an ACOPRecognise that departure from an ACOP needs an evidenced equivalent approach.A procedure uses a different method from an ACOP. What evidence would you want to see?
Use of HSG and INDG documentsSelect detailed HSG guidance for complex decisions and INDG leaflets for awareness or simple briefings.A supervisor uses a short leaflet as the full procedure for high-risk work. What is missing?
Legal register managementKeep duties, guidance, internal procedures and review triggers connected.An audit finds obsolete guidance in several site files. What system weakness does this indicate?
Continuous improvementUse incidents, inspections, enforcement and guidance changes to update arrangements.A near miss shows the procedure was based on old guidance. What should happen next?

What are the warning signs that official guidance is not being managed well?

Weak guidance management usually appears as outdated documents, unclear ownership and controls that do not match current HSE expectations.

The harm is indirect but serious. If a business uses out-of-date or poorly interpreted guidance, people may be trained to the wrong standard, equipment may be bought without the right specification, risk assessments may miss important controls and supervisors may audit the wrong things.

These warning signs should trigger review before an incident, enforcement visit or civil claim exposes the gap.

Warning signs and practical consequences
Warning signHow it can cause harm or non-complianceHow it may show up at work
The legal register only lists legislationACOPs and guidance are not translated into practical control standards.Procedures quote the law but do not explain how the work should be controlled.
Guidance links are broken or outdatedPeople may rely on withdrawn or superseded standards.Old PDFs in folders, dead web links, no review date or no owner.
Generic procedures copy HSE wordingControls may not fit the actual task, site, equipment or people.Workers cannot explain what the procedure means for their work.
Short leaflets are used for complex decisionsHigh-risk work may be under-controlled because the deeper ACOP or HSG has not been consulted.Brief INDG guidance used as the only standard for technical work.
No evidence of equivalent complianceA business may struggle to justify departure from an ACOP if challenged.Procedures differ from ACOP expectations but no competent review is recorded.
Training does not mention source or standardWorkers may learn a rule without understanding when to escalate or report a gap.Training slides have no source references, review dates or link to the risk assessment.

Standards named on this page are background context. Confirm the current edition, scope and exact requirements from an authorised copy before applying them. The open official sources below support the specific public-law and regulator guidance claims they are cited for.

What do the acronyms and key terms mean?

The main acronyms should be defined clearly so learners and non-specialists can follow the guidance.

Acronyms and terminology
Acronym or termWhat it meansWhy it matters
ACOPApproved Code of Practice.A recognised HSE-approved way of complying with certain legal duties, with special legal status.
HSGHealth and Safety Guidance.A common HSE publication series used for practical, technical or management guidance.
INDGHSE information document or leaflet series.Usually a shorter guide for briefings, awareness and small-business explanation.
HSEHealth and Safety Executive.The regulator for many workplaces in Great Britain and publisher of many official guidance documents.
HSWAHealth and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.The main Act setting broad health and safety duties and providing for ACOPs.
RAMSRisk assessment and method statement.A common workplace document used to translate law and guidance into task controls.
ISOInternational Organization for Standardization.Produces standards such as ISO 45001 that can support structured management systems.

Which BuildOut documents support this topic?

Download individual editable BuildOut documents for this topic. Procedures and plans contain completed arrangements; forms, checklists, assessments, RAMS and permits are blank masters. Registers include separate worked examples.

DocumentPurpose and contentEditable download
Legal and other requirements register
BOUK-REG-GOV-01 · Blank register with separate worked entries · v1.1
A detailed GB construction legal baseline with 142 requirement entries, environmental permits and consents, national overlays and eight completed decisions, plus a blank live register.Download XLSX
Read preview

Review and adapt the documents for your organisation, activities and jurisdiction before approval and issue. Open the SHAREms management-system hierarchy to find each document under its parent policy.

Return to SHARE home