SHARE Knowledge Hub

Process Safety Responsibilities and Accountability

Process-safety accountability means a named person has authority, competence and resources for each major-accident barrier and for decisions when it is impaired. A RACI chart alone cannot make a transfer safe: the operator must know whom to call, the supervisor must control the task, the technical authority must judge the barrier, and the release owner must record why work can resume.

Updated 2026-10-19UK focus

Understanding Process Safety Responsibilities and Accountability

Process-safety accountability means a named person has authority, competence and resources for each major-accident barrier and for decisions when it is impaired. A RACI chart alone cannot make a transfer safe: the operator must know whom to call, the supervisor must control the task, the technical authority must judge the barrier, and the release owner must record why work can resume.

Why this matters at work

Emergency plans should specify who declares an incident, who commands at the scene and in the control room, who may isolate or shut down, who communicates with external responders and the public, and who maintains a reliable personnel and inventory picture. Roles must be resilient to absence, injury and communications failure.

Test accountability by sampling recent high-consequence decisions: a deferred examination, extended bypass, process change, emergency exercise failure and restart. For each, ask who knew the scenario, who approved, which technical advice was used, what restriction protected the interim period and whether restoration was verified.

How organisations manage this in practice

Minimum assurance evidence for operations manager and plant control should trace one live or recently completed case through these checkpoints: Control: Own current plant state and limits [Operating standard]; Decide: Set stop and restart authority [Delegation]; Coordinate: Manage work, change and technical advice [Shift plan]. Confirm that the named authority was competent and available when needed, source evidence was current, exceptions and dissent remained visible, affected roles received the decision and the final condition was verified in the field. Record any failed hand-off as a governance finding with an accountable corrective owner.

A plant or process change can alter the hazard and the role required to control it. Change review should identify the affected scenario, engineering basis, procedures, training, maintenance, emergency response and ownership of new controls. A project handover is incomplete until the receiving team has information and authority to operate the changed plant safely.

Minimum assurance evidence for change proposal, approval and implementation roles should trace one live or recently completed case through these checkpoints: Propose: Describe need and affected scenarios [Change request]; Approve: Use competent multidisciplinary review [MOC record]; Verify: Reconcile implementation and information [Closeout]. Confirm that the named authority was competent and available when needed, source evidence was current, exceptions and dissent remained visible, affected roles received the decision and the final condition was verified in the field. Record any failed hand-off as a governance finding with an accountable corrective owner.

SHAREsimulate

How can I practise this topic in 3D?

A proposed open gate defeats the closed perimeter
3D workplace practiceSHAREsim

A proposed open gate defeats the closed perimeter

All related inspection points 3 across 1 location
Crown Fuels terminal 3 inspection points

Practice in the SHAREhub environment. Browser practice is separate from workplace competence and formal learning records.

What do process safety responsibilities and accountability involve?

They define who must do what, who can decide, who verifies and who remains accountable when risk is delegated.

Process safety accountability is not the same as saying everyone is responsible for safety. Everyone has a role, but major accident hazards need clear ownership. Someone must own the risk, someone must own the barrier, someone must own the procedure, someone must approve deviations, and someone must verify that actions reduce risk.

Accountability becomes most important at interfaces: operations and maintenance, projects and live plant, contractor and client, engineering and production, board and site, shift handover and emergency response. Many serious failures occur where people assumed someone else owned the control.

Accountability elementWhat it meansEvidence
Risk ownerPerson accountable for a major accident scenario or asset risk.Risk register and governance record.
Barrier ownerPerson accountable for a safety-critical control remaining effective.Barrier register and performance standard.
Technical authorityCompetent person or function that approves technical standards and deviations.Technical authority framework.
Decision rightsDefined authority to approve change, impairment, restart or risk acceptance.Delegation and approval matrix.
Task responsibilityWho plans, briefs, executes, checks and hands back work.Procedure, permit and handover records.
Assurance ownerWho verifies controls and action effectiveness.Monitoring/audit programme.

Map the scenario and safeguards before assigning titles. A high-high trip has a design authority, test owner, impairment decision owner, operator who sees the bypass, supervisor who stops transfer, and a manager who funds repair. Identify who can authorise temporary operation and under what evidence. Contractors and handovers must be included. Accountability is demonstrated by a traceable decision and field closure, not a generic organisational chart.

Source: HSE COMAH 2015 guidance

Source: HSE leadership for the major hazard industries INDG277

A bypass without a named decision owner creates a harm path: delivery proceeds with an emergency shutdown function unavailable, a transfer upset is not stopped, and a release can expose people to fire, blast or harmful material. The line operator should not silently accept that risk; the authorised owner must hold the transfer until protection is proved. Source: HSE COMAH 2015 guidance

How can the hierarchy of controls guide accountable decisions on major accident risk reduction?

Eliminate, Reduce including substitution, Isolate, Control, personal protective equipment (PPE) and Discipline (ERICPD) is a prompt for decisions. HSE’s five-level hierarchy prioritises elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and PPE. They are related frameworks, not identical laws; apply them to the actual task and check the resulting control.

Eliminate a hazardous transfer or inventory where a design change makes the barrier unnecessary; the process owner and technical authority must approve the changed hazard basis.

Substitute or reduce the hazardous substance, inventory or transfer rate where feasible. Procurement cannot make this a unilateral change; process engineering owns compatibility and scenario review.

Isolate and engineer with independent trips, containment and relief. Assign one owner for performance standard, proof test, bypass authorisation and restoration. A missing name or unproved protection is a hold.

Control, PPE and Discipline: procedures, permits, role training, escalation and audit sustain engineered safeguards. PPE is residual task protection. ERICPD helps choose controls, while HSE’s five-level hierarchy expresses priority; neither assigns decision rights by itself.

Source: HSE hierarchy of controls

Source: HSE COMAH 2015 guidance

One barrier-accountability owner coordinates performance and escalation; this does not mean one person designs, tests, authorises and independently checks their own work. Name separately who performs the test, judges technical acceptance/alternative protection, authorises the bypass and controls operations release. RACI means Responsible, Accountable, Consulted and Informed.

How should accountability flow through the organisation?

Accountability should flow down through clear roles and back up through evidence, escalation and review.

A useful model is: board accountability -> site/asset ownership -> technical authority standards -> line management control -> supervisor verification -> worker/contractor task responsibility -> assurance feedback -> management review. This is not bureaucracy; it prevents safety-critical decisions disappearing into gaps.

The board cannot personally check every valve, but it remains accountable for ensuring competent arrangements exist. A worker can stop a job, but they should not carry the burden of deciding whether a degraded major accident barrier is acceptable for continued operation.

LevelAccountability focusEvidence flow back up
Board/senior leadershipSet risk appetite, resources and assurance expectations.Barrier dashboard, red actions and audit findings.
Site/asset managerOwn local major accident risk and operating discipline.Risk reviews and escalation logs.
Technical authoritySet standards and approve deviations or complex changes.Technical approvals and deviation register.
Operations/maintenance managerControl routine work, maintenance, permits and competence.KPIs, backlog and verification records.
SupervisorBrief, coordinate and verify work as done.Shift records, checks and stop-work actions.
Worker/contractorFollow controls, report weak signals and stop unsafe work.Task records, observations and near-miss reports.
Assurance/auditTest whether the system works in reality.Findings, grading and verified actions.

How does accountability apply to a bypassed safety-critical trip?

A worked example shows why decision rights matter when a safety-critical barrier is impaired.

Crownway Fuels Ltd needs to test an emergency shutdown trip on a loading system. The trip is bypassed temporarily for testing. A tanker delivery arrives early, and the shift team considers continuing the transfer because the trip will only be bypassed for a short time. This is where accountability must be explicit.

The operator may know the bypass exists, but the operator should not be left to accept the risk informally. The supervisor must control the task, the operations manager must decide whether transfer can proceed, the technical authority may need to approve temporary controls, and senior leadership must define which bypasses require stop or escalation.

RoleRACI positionAccountability and evidence expected
OperatorResponsibleIdentify the bypass status, follow the authorised procedure, stop if conditions are outside the permit and record the field condition.
Supervisor / permit authorityAccountable for task controlConfirm the bypass is tagged, briefed, time-limited and reflected in the permit, shift handover and temporary-control plan.
Technical authorityConsulted / approval where requiredConfirm whether the trip is safety-critical, what risk is created, which temporary controls are credible and whether operation can continue.
Maintenance / instrument technicianResponsible for test and reinstatementApply/remove the bypass under control, complete functional proof test, record results and confirm the barrier is restored.
Asset owner / operations managerAccountable for operational risk acceptanceDecide whether transfer, start-up or continued operation is allowed and document authority, expiry and restrictions.
Site leaderInformed / escalated for high-risk deviationReview repeated bypasses, overdue reinstatement, production pressure and resource causes in management review.
Process safety / assurance leadConsulted / verifiesSample the bypass record, temporary controls, proof-test evidence and learning actions for effectiveness.

Operational example: decisions and evidence

Task material and setting: Crownway Fuels Ltd bypasses the independent emergency shutdown trip on a fuel-loading line for a planned proof test as a tanker arrives early.

People and prerequisites: Instrument specialist controls the test; operator knows bypass status; supervisor controls the transfer; technical authority judges temporary protection; operations manager owns stop/release.

Before: Define bypass permit, duration, isolation, compensating measures, communication, test acceptance and who can reject a transfer.

During: Keep the line out of normal transfer while the trip is bypassed; record status at the control room and tanker interface.

Hold or stop: Do not let schedule pressure transfer the acceptance decision to an operator without authority or evidence; stop until the trip is restored or a competent approved alternative exists.

Completion and hand back: Test and restore the trip, remove the bypass, reconcile logs and obtain the named release owner’s sign-off.

Evidence: Bypass permit, cause-and-effect/test record, control-room log, decision rights, communications and verified handback.

Source: HSE COMAH 2015 guidance

Source: HSE leadership for the major hazard industries INDG277

Out-of-hours branch: use the authorised deputy if the operations manager is unavailable. If a contractor disputes the bypass register or shift handover conflicts, hold the transfer, reconcile actual plant status against the evidence with the technical authority and tell the tanker/interface supervisor. Record the agreed boundary, verification reference, decision functions and final operations handback before release. Neither a senior signature nor production pressure resolves an unknown barrier state; operator duties remain.

Where do responsibilities and accountability commonly fail?

Failures arise where roles are vague, technical authority is bypassed or interfaces are not owned.

The phrase 'everyone is responsible' can hide the fact that no one owns the difficult decisions. Process safety needs clarity because barrier impairment, MOC, restart, risk acceptance and emergency response can involve high-consequence judgement.

Accountability failures often appear as delayed actions, unclear handover, HSE being expected to own line-management controls, engineers not consulted, contractors outside the system or supervisors lacking authority to stop work.

Failure modeHow it developsWhat competent management does
Everyone owns itNo named person owns barrier health or action close-out.Assign risk, barrier and action owners.
HSE owns safetyLine managers outsource operational control.Define line ownership and adviser support.
Technical authority bypassedProduction approves technical deviation alone.Set decision rights for deviations and MOC.
Contractor interface gapClient and contractor assume the other owns controls.Bridge document, induction and permit responsibilities.
Shift handover weakBarrier status or abnormal condition is not transferred.Handover standard and verification.
Action owner lacks authorityPerson assigned action cannot resource or change system.Match owner to decision power.
Risk acceptance informalTemporary operation continues without senior approval.Formal risk acceptance with expiry and controls.

What evidence proves accountability is clear?

Evidence should show roles, competence, authority, escalation and action ownership in routine and abnormal conditions.

A good accountability system can be sampled. Pick one major accident scenario and ask who owns the risk, who owns each barrier, who maintains it, who verifies it, who approves impairment, who receives red indicators and who can stop operation. If those answers are unclear, the accountability system is weak.

The evidence should include formal documents and live records. Role descriptions are useful, but permit records, MOC decisions, bypass approvals, shift handovers and action trackers show whether accountability works in practice.

Evidence itemWhat good looks likeWeakness to challenge
Organisation chartRoles reflect actual control of plant, people and decisions.Chart does not match how work is done.
RACI matrixResponsible, accountable, consulted and informed roles defined for critical processes.Matrix exists but misses abnormal work.
Technical authority frameworkCompetence and decision rights are clear.Technical decisions made by pressure or seniority.
Delegation of authorityRisk acceptance, MOC, bypass and restart approvals are defined.Informal approvals for high-risk deviations.
Competence recordsRole holders trained and authorised for responsibility.Named owners lack competence or time.
Action trackerActions have owners with authority and evidence of closure.Actions assigned to generic departments.
Handover recordsBarrier impairments and abnormal conditions are transferred.Handover misses safety-critical status.

How should accountability be audited?

Audit accountability by following a real scenario, barrier or action across organisational levels.

Do not audit accountability only by reading role descriptions. Select a live or recent issue: an overdue proof test, open MOC, bypassed alarm, deferred maintenance item, contractor interface or abnormal start-up. Follow it through the organisation and ask who knew, who decided, who owned the risk and who verified the action.

A strong audit will show whether accountability flows both ways: expectations flow down to work, and evidence flows back to leaders.

Audit sampleQuestionEvidence
Overdue critical maintenanceWho owns the risk and approves deferral?Backlog, risk ranking and approval.
MOC actionWho can close it and what evidence is needed?MOC close-out record.
Bypassed alarm/tripWho authorised the bypass and temporary controls?Bypass register and permit.
Contractor high-risk taskWhere do client and contractor responsibilities meet?Bridge document and permit.
Incident actionDoes the owner have authority to change the system?Action tracker and verification.
Board reviewDo leaders see unresolved accountability gaps?Minutes and escalation.

What do learners commonly misunderstand?

The common mistake is treating responsibility as a list of job titles rather than a system of decision rights and evidence.

A strong answer explains how accountability works during normal, abnormal and emergency conditions. It should include RACI, technical authority, competence, line ownership, escalation and verification.

A weak answer says 'management is responsible and employees must cooperate' without showing how major accident controls are owned.

Learner questionStrong answer should includeWeak answer to avoid
Why is 'everyone is responsible' insufficient?Major accident barriers need named owners and decision rights.It creates shared responsibility.
What is technical authority?A competent function/person that sets standards and approves technical decisions.The senior engineer.
How should contractors be included?Define interfaces, rules, permits, competence and assurance.Give them the site rules.
What is a RACI useful for?Clarifying responsible, accountable, consulted and informed roles.Replacing procedures.
How do you audit accountability?Follow a live scenario/action through roles, decisions and evidence.Check job descriptions.

How should the control be managed and reviewed?

For a GB workplace, HSE guidance supports identifying the actual risk, taking practical protective steps and reviewing whether they work. Name the decision owner, check the control during the real task and correct a failed arrangement. Apply the separate Northern Ireland duties and guidance where the work is in NI.

GB management guidance: HSE managing health and safety

What training and competence are needed?

Training should make decision rights, escalation and barrier ownership clear for normal, abnormal and emergency work.

Training should be role-based. General awareness creates a baseline, but supervisors, managers, advisers and senior leaders need different levels of decision-making, verification and escalation competence.

RoleWhat to demonstrateWho checksRecord and reassessment
Operators and contractorsIdentify barrier impairment and escalation route.Supervisor uses a bypass scenario.Role brief and stop record.
Supervisors and operations managersMake hold/release decisions within authority and record rationale.Technical authority observes simulation.Permit and handback evidence.
Technical authoritiesDefine performance, approve temporary protection and verify restoration.Independent peer reviews a real case.Design/test approval.
Senior leaders and auditorsProvide resources and sample decision rights across shifts.Independent assurance traces a recent bypass.Governance and closure record.

Source context: HSE COMAH 2015 guidance

What do the acronyms and key terms mean?

Acronyms should be understood before they are used in assessments, briefings, audits or learning answers.

Acronyms can exclude newer readers if they are not explained. This section keeps the main terms available at the end of the page so the article stays readable while still supporting learners and audit users.

AcronymMeaningPlain-English use
COMAHControl of Major Accident HazardsMajor-accident regime with separate GB and Northern Ireland regulations; check site threshold.
PSMProcess Safety ManagementManagement of major accident hazard controls.
MOCManagement of ChangeControlled review before changes are made.
SCESafety Critical ElementA system, structure or component whose failure could contribute to a major accident.
KPIKey Performance IndicatorA measure used to track performance.