SHARE Knowledge Hub

Defences, compensation and SARHA in workplace claims

A workplace injury can lead to a civil claim for compensation as well as separate action under health and safety law. Liability, causation, loss and any defence depend on the facts and the law of the relevant UK jurisdiction. In England and Wales, the Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015 asks a court to consider specified context; it does not excuse unsafe work or decide a claim automatically.

Updated 2026-10-22UK focusLegal informationDN1 1.5

Understanding Defences, compensation and SARHA in workplace claims

Defences, compensation and SARHA considerations is a legal-theory, governance and claims-process topic for UK occupational safety and health. It explains how civil negligence claims and compensation differ from criminal enforcement and internal prevention, how evidence informs possible defences, and the limited England-and-Wales context of the Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015. It is not a substitute for legal advice on a live dispute.

Why this matters at work

Hassam v Rabot [2024] UKSC 11 explains assessment of combined injury effects and avoidance of double counting. Its dispute concerned road-traffic whiplash and non-whiplash injuries; its statutory tariff must not be applied as a workplace injury tariff. BAE Systems v Konczak [2017] EWCA Civ 1188, paragraphs 60–72, separates divisibility of harm from causative contribution and pre-existing vulnerability. That employment-discrimination psychiatric-injury case requires an evidential basis for apportionment; a manager’s estimate of competing causes is insufficient.

Holmes v Poeton [2023] EWCA Civ 1377 distinguishes contribution to an injury from contribution to the risk of developing it. The Court of Appeal accepted that material contribution can apply to indivisible injury, but allowed the employer’s appeal because individual causation was not proved on the evidence. Exposure, a plausible mechanism or an epidemiological association alone should not be presented as a judicial finding that the exposure caused this person’s disease.

How organisations manage this in practice

Reasonable care is demonstrated through operational evidence: engineered safety, maintained plant, competent supervision, exposure control, consultation, action on warnings and learning across similar operations. A legal register without field implementation does not prevent injury or establish reasonable care.

Plan: understand the risk profile, legal requirements, vulnerable groups, objectives and resources. Do: organise responsibilities, competence, worker involvement and source controls. Check: monitor critical controls, inspect, investigate and audit. Act: review performance, learn and change the system.

Where an employee is injured in the course of employment because of defective equipment provided by the employer and the defect is attributable wholly or partly to a third party's fault, the GB Employer’s Liability (Defective Equipment) Act 1969 can deem the injury attributable to the employer's negligence for the employee's action. Contribution or recovery from the third party may follow.

Civil liability is best managed by preventing harm, not by writing defensively after it. HSWA 1974 requires employers, so far as is reasonably practicable, to ensure employees' health, safety and welfare and to protect others affected by the undertaking. Regulations add specific controls. HSG65 provides a Plan, Do, Check, Act management model.

Separate the incident facts from legal arguments

Begin with jurisdiction, the people affected and the actual controls. A possible civil argument, a criminal duty and a contextual SARHA consideration answer different questions; none should be treated as a promised outcome.

One incident, several legal questions

Illustrative example. A visitor injury leads to questions about care, shared responsibility and records.

Decision. Preserve the factual record and ask the appropriate legal owner to identify the applicable route.

Evidence to check. Contemporaneous observations, actual control decisions and relevant jurisdiction.

Hold or escalation point. Do not rewrite records to improve a defence or assume one legal framework applies everywhere.

Follow-up. Link the evidence-preservation and civil-proceedings guidance to the authorised review.

Build the chronology before considering interpretations

Preserved facts and possible legal interpretations belong in different lanes. A record of good intent does not guarantee a defence or compensation result.

Preserve what happened before interpreting it

Preserve what happened before interpreting it. The exact existing manufacturing records scene shows an envelope, inert letter, separate receipt notebook and archival folder. New markers connect source material, chronology and custodianship. No actual incident, original legal evidence, liability or compensation result is depicted.
A record and a legal interpretation are distinct. The full topic retains territorial and claim-specific limitations; the illustration guarantees no outcome.
Full written explanation

Employer handling-injury example: preserve the source record, receipt history and uncertainty without rewriting events.

  1. Protect the original material. Preserve relevant records and identify their source and custodian. Immediate welfare and work controls remain separate priorities.
  2. Build a factual chronology. Record what was received, created or observed and when. Keep missing facts, conflicting accounts and later recollection explicit.
  3. Separate the legal questions. Give the verified record to the insurer and appropriately qualified adviser for the jurisdiction and issue. Good intent is not a guaranteed defence.

Change the pathway

  • Do not improve the past. Do not backdate, overwrite or manufacture an earlier assessment or inspection.
  • Distinguish records from findings. An inert teaching notebook is not an original timestamp or proof of reasonable care.
  • Retain independent decisions. Liability, disclosure, limitation and settlement need claim-specific qualified advice.

Evidence check: A record and a legal interpretation are distinct. The full topic retains territorial and claim-specific limitations; the illustration guarantees no outcome.

Full territorial, insurance, limitation and SARHA context

Primary references: Official SARHA Act text: scope and factors (England and Wales) · Official SARHA commencement and transitional provisions

Open the complete HD image (new tab)Download image

Full territorial, insurance, limitation and SARHA context

Primary references: Official SARHA Act text: scope and factors (England and Wales) · Official SARHA commencement and transitional provisions

Entrance to a traditional British courthouse. Photorealistic illustration.
Illustrative UK workplace scene. Read the practical checks below for responsibilities, evidence and limits. Download image · Download smaller image
  1. Preserve

    Protect original evidence and record who created or obtained it and when; attend to immediate welfare and controls.

  2. Separate fact from interpretation

    Mark uncertainty and conflicting accounts. Label a proposed interpretation as a question rather than an established finding.

  3. Qualified advice

    Give the verified record to an appropriately qualified adviser for the applicable jurisdiction and issue.

This example supplies no guaranteed defence, entitlement or outcome.

What key facts should people know first about defences, compensation and SARHA?

The key fact is that civil liability is evidence-led and legal decisions should be made by competent legal or insurer advisers.

This page is general workplace information, not legal advice. It does not tell any organisation whether it is liable, whether a claim will succeed or whether a defence should be pleaded. Those decisions belong with solicitors, insurers and the relevant court process.

Health and safety professionals still have an important role. They help prevent harm before incidents and, after an incident, they help preserve accurate facts, identify what happened, support learning and provide reliable records. They should avoid statements that admit liability, blame individuals without evidence, speculate about causation, coach witnesses or alter records.

A strong organisation treats claim defensibility as an outcome of good management, not as a post-incident tactic. If risk assessments, training, maintenance, supervision and action close-out are poor before an incident, it is difficult to manufacture credibility afterwards.

Key facts - Key facts
Fact Why it matters
Compensation is not punishment Civil compensation is mainly about financial remedy for proven loss, while criminal enforcement punishes or deters wrongdoing.
Defences depend on facts No defence works in the abstract; evidence, causation and legal context matter.
SARHA is limited It requires courts to consider social action, responsibility and heroism contexts but is not a blanket shield.
ERRA changed statutory breach claims Breach of health and safety legislation does not usually create automatic civil liability by itself.
Evidence must be preserved Contemporaneous records usually carry more weight than reconstructed explanations.

What do defences, compensation and SARHA mean in health and safety claims?

They describe how civil claims may be valued, challenged and considered by a court after workplace harm.

A civil health and safety claim usually asks whether a defendant owed a duty of care, breached that duty and caused compensable harm. In Scotland, the legal language and procedure differ, but the practical safety lesson is similar: decisions turn on duty, evidence, causation, reasonableness and loss. Civil-claim boundary: HSE civil-law compensation guidance.

Compensation concerns the losses claimed. Defences concern why liability should not be found, should be reduced or should be limited. SARHA is a statutory consideration in England and Wales that tells courts to consider whether the defendant acted for the benefit of society, demonstrated a generally responsible approach, or acted heroically in an emergency.

For health and safety people, the important boundary is professional discipline. They can explain the management system, evidence and lessons learned; they should not provide legal opinions on liability unless they are appropriately qualified and instructed to do so.

Core concepts - Core concepts
Concept Plain-English meaning Workplace implication
Duty of care A legal duty to take reasonable care for another person's safety. Know who may be affected by the undertaking.
Breach Failure to meet the required standard of care. Records should show suitable assessment, control, training and review.
Causation The link between breach and harm. Incident investigation should separate facts from assumptions.
Compensation Financial remedy for proven injury, loss and future impact. Accurate records help determine what happened and what was affected.
Defence An argument that liability is not established, reduced or legally limited. Legal teams need reliable evidence, not speculation.
SARHA A statutory context the court must consider in certain claims. Responsible conduct matters, but SARHA does not excuse poor control.

What is compensation trying to achieve?

Compensation aims to provide a civil financial remedy for proven harm and loss.

In personal injury claims, compensation may include general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, and special damages for financial losses such as loss of earnings, care, treatment costs, travel, equipment or future losses. The exact categories and valuation are legal matters, but managers should understand why evidence is requested.

Health and safety records may influence liability and causation. Payroll, absence, occupational health, training, maintenance, CCTV, photographs, inspection records and witness accounts may all become relevant. That does not mean every record should be handed around informally. Documents should be managed lawfully, proportionately and through the organisation's claims, insurer and legal process.

Compensation is separate from criminal enforcement. A serious incident may generate a civil claim, an HSE investigation, RIDDOR reporting, internal disciplinary issues, insurance action and learning review. Those processes interact but are not the same.

A claim must be assessed on evidence of duty, breach, causation and loss. The HSE does not run civil claims or decide damages. A criminal investigation, insurer response and civil action may proceed on different questions and timelines; preserve facts for each without assuming that one outcome decides another.

Compensation concepts - Compensation concepts
Category What it may cover Evidence that may be relevant
Pain, suffering and loss of amenity The injury and its effect on life. Medical evidence and witness evidence.
Loss of earnings Past or future income impact. Payroll, absence records, return-to-work and capability evidence.
Care and assistance Support needed because of the injury. Care records, statements and medical evidence.
Treatment and rehabilitation Reasonable treatment or recovery costs. Medical advice, invoices and rehab plans.
Equipment or adaptations Practical aids or adjustments. Occupational health, ergonomic or medical recommendations.
Legal costs and process costs Costs depend on claim route and court rules. Handled through insurer and legal advisers.

What defences may be relevant in workplace injury claims?

Defences usually challenge duty, breach, causation, loss, limitation or the claimant's own contribution.

A defence is not a moral argument that the organisation is a good employer. It is a structured legal response to the claim. The strongest practical support for a defence is reliable evidence that the organisation assessed the risk, applied suitable controls, trained and supervised people, maintained equipment, acted on defects and responded to change. Contributory-fault and limitation routes: Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945; NI Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1948; Limitation Act 1980; NI Limitation Order 1989.

Contributory negligence may arise where the claimant's own conduct contributed to the harm. Voluntary assumption of risk is much narrower and should not be casually assumed in employment situations. Limitation may prevent or restrict claims brought too late, subject to legal rules and discretion. Causation may be contested where the injury was not caused by the alleged breach or where alternative causes exist.

Health and safety advisers should describe what the records show and what the investigation found. They should not decide whether a legal defence will succeed.

Common defence themes - Common defence themes
Theme What it asks Useful evidence
No duty or limited duty Was the defendant responsible for this person or risk? Contracts, site control, role allocation, visitor/contractor arrangements.
No breach Did the defendant take reasonable care in the circumstances? Which controls were actually in place? Risk assessments, training, inspections, maintenance, supervision and audits.
Causation Did the alleged breach cause the injury or loss? Incident facts, medical evidence, timeline, photographs and witness accounts.
Contributory negligence Did the claimant's own fault contribute? Training, clear instructions, supervision, PPE issue/use and behavioural evidence.
Limitation Was the claim brought within the relevant time limit? Incident date, knowledge date, correspondence and legal advice.
Reasonable conduct/SARHA context Was the defendant acting responsibly, socially or heroically? Planning records, emergency context, decision rationale and conduct evidence.

What does SARHA actually do?

SARHA requires courts in England and Wales to consider specific context, but it does not give automatic immunity.

The Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015 is short but often misunderstood. It tells the court to have regard to whether the defendant was acting for the benefit of society, demonstrated a predominantly responsible approach towards protecting safety, or acted heroically by intervening in an emergency.

SARHA does not tell the court what result to reach. It does not remove the duty to manage risk, does not excuse reckless behaviour and does not mean that a business can ignore foreseeable hazards because it had good intentions. It is a contextual factor for the court.

In health and safety management, SARHA is best understood as a reminder that responsible conduct matters. If an organisation can show sensible planning, proportionate controls and good-faith emergency response, that context may be relevant. If records show ignored hazards, poor training or unsafe shortcuts, SARHA is unlikely to rescue credibility.

Section 1 sets the court-context question; sections 2 to 4 address social action, a predominantly responsible approach to protecting safety, and heroic emergency intervention. The Act extends to England and Wales only. It does not reverse the burden of proof, erase negligence, or prevent a worker from making a claim. A legal adviser should decide whether it is relevant on the actual facts. England and Wales statutory context: Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015.

For an England and Wales claim, first identify the decision governed by SARHA section 1: the court is considering alleged negligence or breach of statutory duty and deciding what care the person was required to take. Evidence about responsible conduct should relate to the activity in which the alleged failure occurred. A good annual audit elsewhere in the business cannot, by itself, establish how this particular task was planned and controlled. Preserve the actual instructions, decisions and emergency circumstances, and ask the claim adviser how they bear on the statutory context. This is a practical evidence example, not a prediction of the court’s finding.

SARHA sections in plain English - SARHA sections in plain English
SARHA theme What the court considers Practical caution
Social action Was the person acting for the benefit of society or any of its members? This may matter for volunteering or public benefit activity, but risks still need control.
Responsibility Did the person demonstrate a predominantly responsible approach to protecting safety? Good records and sensible systems matter more than slogans.
Heroism Was the person acting heroically by intervening in an emergency? Emergency context may be relevant, but reckless conduct is not automatically excused.
Limit The Act does not decide the claim by itself. Always obtain legal advice before relying on SARHA in a claim.

How should claims-related information and evidence be managed?

Evidence should be preserved, factual, complete, traceable and handled through the proper legal, insurer and data protection route.

After an incident, the first priorities remain welfare, emergency response and making the area safe. Once immediate needs are controlled, evidence should be preserved. That may include photographs, CCTV, equipment condition, maintenance records, training evidence, risk assessments, permits, inspection records, witness details, environmental conditions, PPE and communications.

The investigation report should separate facts, analysis, findings and recommendations. Avoid speculative wording such as 'we were definitely liable', 'the worker was at fault' or 'this was just bad luck' unless that conclusion is properly evidenced and legally reviewed. Witnesses should give their own account in their own words; they should not be coached into a preferred version.

Legal privilege is specialist and should not be assumed. If the organisation needs privileged legal advice, solicitors should be involved early. Routine health and safety records, incident reports and audit documents are not made privileged simply by marking them confidential.

Evidence handling - Evidence handling
Evidence type Good handling Common mistake
Scene evidence Photograph, isolate and preserve relevant equipment or conditions. Cleaning up or repairing before evidence is recorded.
Witness accounts Take timely factual accounts in the witness's own words. Leading questions or group-written statements.
Documents Preserve current and historical versions of assessments, procedures and records. Editing or recreating records after the incident.
Digital records Secure CCTV, telematics, access logs, emails and system data quickly. Allowing automatic overwrite or uncontrolled sharing.
Investigation report Separate facts, analysis, root causes and actions. Speculating on legal liability or blaming without evidence.
Insurer/legal route Notify as required and follow advice on disclosure and privilege. Trying to manage a claim informally outside policy conditions.

How should insurers and legal advisers be involved?

Insurers and legal advisers should be involved early enough to protect policy conditions, evidence quality and communication discipline.

Employers' liability insurance is a legal requirement for most employers. Insurance policies normally contain notification and cooperation conditions. Delayed notification, missing documents or unmanaged admissions can create avoidable difficulty. The safety team should know the organisation's escalation route before a serious incident occurs.

Involving insurers does not mean hiding learning. A well-run organisation can both cooperate with claims handling and improve safety. The key is discipline: welfare support, factual records, legal notification, regulator cooperation where required, and learning actions that are verified rather than performative.

Communications with injured people should be humane and careful. Organisations can express concern, provide support and explain processes without making premature legal admissions.

Insurer and adviser interface - Insurer and adviser interface
Action Why it matters
Notify according to policy Protects policy conditions and allows early advice.
Preserve evidence Supports accurate liability, causation and quantum decisions.
Coordinate communications Avoids inconsistent messages to claimant, regulator, insurer and workforce.
Track actions Shows learning and prevents recurrence without prejudging liability.
Control document access Protects personal data, legal strategy and record integrity.

What should the claims defensibility register include?

The register should identify high-value evidence, ownership, retention, notification triggers and improvement actions.

A claims-readiness register is useful only if it improves real prevention and evidence quality. For each material hazard, identify the responsible control owner, the actual records that show the control operated, where they are stored, who can preserve them after an incident, and the retention decision. A missing inspection or contradictory date is a reason to investigate the control and preserve the discrepancy, not to edit the file until it looks defensible. Trend repeated claim themes back into risk assessment and field verification while keeping personal claim data restricted.

Claims defensibility and evidence register - Claims defensibility and evidence register
Risk or issue Control Evidence
Incident evidence lost Immediate evidence preservation process and responsible owner. Incident pack, photographs, CCTV request and equipment quarantine.
Unclear liability narrative Structured investigation separating facts, causes and actions. Investigation report, witness accounts and timeline.
Late insurer notification Claims notification trigger in incident procedure. Notification record and policy reference.
Speculative admissions Manager training and communication controls. Briefing notes, escalation route and reviewed statements.
Weak pre-incident evidence Management system records and periodic assurance checks. Training, maintenance, risk assessment and audit records.
Poor learning from claims Trend review and action close-out. Claims review, lessons learned and management review minutes.

How can the hierarchy of controls prevent machinery injury when responding to a reported interlock defect?

A retail facilities team changing high-level signage may be able to lower the sign or use a suitable guarded platform; a construction crew inspecting a roof needs different edge, access and rescue arrangements. The owner checks the actual work height, task duration, surface and people below before choosing equipment.

What training supports better handling of claims-related information?

Training should help people record facts, preserve evidence, communicate carefully and escalate correctly.

General awareness is useful for supervisors, HSE advisers, HR and managers who may be involved in incident response. It should cover civil versus criminal processes, evidence preservation, witness handling, insurer notification, data protection, confidentiality and professional boundaries.

More detailed training is needed for people who investigate serious incidents or manage claims interfaces. They need to understand root cause analysis, document control, legal privilege boundaries, worker communication, regulator contact, insurer expectations and action tracking.

The aim is not to turn managers into lawyers. The aim is to stop well-meaning people from damaging evidence, making unsupported statements or missing opportunities to learn.

Competence must be shown in a realistic task or decision, assessed by someone competent, recorded with its scope, and reassessed after material change, a failed control, incident or extended time away from the activity. Attendance alone does not authorise specialist work.

Training levels - Training levels
RoleLearning to testCompetence demonstrationAssessor and recordReassessment trigger
Worker/witnessPrompt factual reporting and welfareGive own account without speculation or coachingSupervisor; dated recordNew evidence or incident
SupervisorPreserve scene and records, notify claims leadRun an evidence-preservation scenarioClaims lead; incident recordProcedure change or missed evidence
HSE/HR adviserSeparate safety learning, privacy and legal decisionsTrace factual controls and restricted data accessManager/legal adviser; audit trailClaim or privacy issue
Manager/insurer liaisonPolicy notice, retention and communication routeShow timely hand-off and versioned recordsInsurer/legal team; notification recordPolicy or jurisdiction change
Legal specialistJurisdiction, limitation, liability and disclosureProfessional review of the live claimQualified lawyer; advice fileNew fact, pleading or law

How should the controls be managed and reviewed?

Assign owners to the significant risks, put the chosen controls into the work plan, check that they work in practice and change them when conditions or evidence change.

HSE describes this as a continuing plan, do, check and act process. For defences compensation and sarha considerations, record who checks the controls, what evidence shows they are working, and which failure stops the work or triggers review. A formal management system is a choice, not a substitute for the applicable legal duties. Read HSE management guidance.

What warning signs show claims-related arrangements are weak?

Warning signs show when records are unreliable, communication is uncontrolled or learning is disconnected from claims.

Records are recreated after incidents

Reconstructed records may damage credibility and obscure what was really controlled at the time.

Managers admit or deny liability informally

Legal positions should be handled through insurers and legal advisers.

Witness accounts are delayed or coached

Late or influenced accounts are less reliable and may be challenged.

Incident reports mix facts and opinions

Speculative conclusions can create confusion and undermine learning.

Insurer notification is ad hoc

Policy conditions and early advice may be missed.

Claims trends are ignored

Repeated claims may reveal control weaknesses that need management action.

What do the acronyms and key terms mean?

These acronyms are commonly used in civil claims and health and safety legal discussion.

Acronyms - Acronyms
TermFull form or definitionMeaning here
CCTV Closed-circuit television Time-limited footage may preserve the event sequence; handle it lawfully.
CPR Civil Procedure Rules England-and-Wales civil procedure, not the NI or Scottish court route.
ELCI Employers' Liability Compulsory Insurance Insurance for employee injury liability; GB and NI instruments differ.
ERRA Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 Section 69 changed the civil effect of some GB safety-law breaches.
HSE Health and Safety Executive GB safety regulator; it does not decide civil compensation.
MoJ Ministry of Justice England-and-Wales justice department; policy background is not case advice.
PSLA Pain, suffering and loss of amenity A head of general damages for pain, suffering and lost enjoyment.
SARHA Social Action, Responsibility and Heroism Act 2015 England-and-Wales court context for social action, responsibility or heroism; no immunity.
Contributory negligenceClaimant contribution to damageA court/legal issue requiring facts and jurisdiction-specific law.