Read the completed bowtie
Worked teaching example: an intact, replaceable lamp in a workplace room. A competent person has selected a suitable guarded work platform where work at height cannot be avoided. This bowtie follows loss of balance or support. Electrical injury, burns and broken glass also need their own assessment; do not open, repair or force a damaged fitting.
Start with the better option: can a suitable ground-level method remove the need to climb? If it can, this work-at-height pathway is avoided. The diagram explores the remaining case where raised access is necessary.
Before the top event
- Overreach or pull at a stuck bulb → Keep the work within a safe reach → Balance or stable support is lost
- The access equipment moves or fails → Use stable, suitable, checked access → Balance or stable support is lost
- A door or another person hits the access → Protect the access from interference → Balance or stable support is lost
- Shock or a hot lamp causes a sudden jerk → Make the electrical supply safe → Let the lamp cool before handling → Balance or stable support is lost
After the top event
- Balance or stable support is lost → Suitable platform guardrails limit a fall → The worker suffers impact injuries
- Balance or stable support is lost → Keep other people out of the landing area → Someone below is struck and injured
- Balance or stable support is lost → Use planned emergency and first-aid arrangements → An injury becomes worse while help is delayed
A person working above floor level
In everyday language: Height and gravity mean a person could fall and be hurt. The height is the source of danger; it is not the accident itself.
Why it belongs here: Someone can be working at height in a controlled way. The bowtie asks how that control might be lost, and what would limit the harm afterwards.
What to check: First consider avoiding raised access. If it remains necessary, assess the actual height, reach, floor, equipment, people nearby and emergency arrangements.
Balance or stable support is lost
In everyday language: The person slips, tips, is jolted, or loses their footing or support while reaching the light. They have lost control, but an injury has not necessarily happened yet.
Why it belongs here: This is the knot of the bowtie. Controls to its left aim to stop this moment. Controls to its right are already in place and act if it happens.
What to check: Keep this event the same on every route. Electric shock and a lamp falling on their own are different top events and would need their own bowties.
Overreach or pull at a stuck bulb
In everyday language: Leaning beyond the safe working position or pulling hard can shift the person's weight and cause a loss of balance.
Why it belongs here: A job that looks quick can still require unsafe reach or force. A chair or a higher step is not a safe way to solve it.
What to check: Position suitable access so the light is within comfortable reach. If the lamp is stuck, damaged or needs unexpected force, stop and obtain competent help.
The access equipment moves or fails
In everyday language: A wheel rolls, a support slips, or damaged equipment gives way. The person can lose support even if they are being careful.
Why it belongs here: Equipment condition, correct setup and the floor all matter. A training certificate cannot make defective access equipment stable.
What to check: Use suitable equipment on a sound, level surface, with the manufacturer's required brakes, locks and supports in place. Reject defects before use.
A door or another person hits the access
In everyday language: Someone opens a door into the platform or walks into it. The impact can jolt the worker or move their support.
Why it belongs here: Other people's normal activities can interfere with the task. Telling only the person changing the bulb does not control that interface.
What to check: Plan the work area, manage doors and pedestrian routes safely, and maintain emergency escape routes.
Shock or a hot lamp causes a sudden jerk
In everyday language: An electric shock or unexpected heat can make the person pull away suddenly and lose balance.
Why it belongs here: Electrical energy and heat are separate hazards. Here they appear only because a sudden movement can trigger the selected balance-loss event.
What to check: Have electrical safety established by a competent person and allow the lamp to cool before handling. Never assume a dark lamp proves the circuit is safe.
Keep the work within a safe reach
In everyday language: Select and position the access so the person can reach the bulb without leaning out or pulling hard. Stop if the task changes.
Why it belongs here: This prevents the overreach or force from turning into a loss of balance. Briefing alone is not enough if the equipment cannot provide a safe position.
What to check: Before climbing, confirm the intended working position and light handling task. Do not improvise with furniture or force a seized bulb; change the method and seek competent help.
Owner: The person planning the task and the person doing it.
What could undermine it: The correct access is unavailable, the light is higher than expected, or pressure to finish discourages stopping.
Depends on: People know the limits of the task; Suitable access equipment is actually available; There is time and authority to stop
Use stable, suitable, checked access
In everyday language: Use the access equipment selected for this task, set up on a sound floor and checked before use. In this example it is a suitable guarded work platform.
Why it belongs here: This addresses slipping, tipping or equipment failure. Stepladders are only an option where the actual risk assessment supports them; a short job alone is not a justification.
What to check: Check condition, surface, position, load and all required brakes or locks against the manufacturer's instructions. Remove defective equipment from use.
Owner: The equipment owner and a competent user.
What could undermine it: A missed defect, an uneven floor, incompatible equipment or an unengaged brake or lock.
Depends on: People know the limits of the task; Suitable access equipment is actually available; The supporting floor remains sound and level
Protect the access from interference
In everyday language: Keep people and moving doors from striking the access while the task is in progress.
Why it belongs here: A controlled work area prevents other activities from knocking the person off balance. It must be practical for the actual room and people using it.
What to check: Agree a usable exclusion area and safe door arrangements before starting. Do not lock people in, obstruct fire exits or rely on a sign that everyone can walk past.
Owner: The task lead and the person responsible for the room.
What could undermine it: The route is reopened, a door arrangement changes, or others have not been told about the work.
Depends on: Other people and doors are managed; People know the limits of the task; There is time and authority to stop
Make the electrical supply safe
In everyday language: A competent person establishes the required safe isolation, prevents unexpected re-energising and verifies the safe condition before work starts.
Why it belongs here: This prevents an electrical shock that could cause a sudden loss of balance. It also addresses a separate serious electrical hazard; this diagram is not an electrical-work procedure.
What to check: Use the correct identified supply and suitable isolation and verification arrangements. A wall switch, warning note, dark lamp or an RCD is not proof of safe isolation. If unsure, stop and use competent electrical help.
Owner: The competent person controlling electrical safety.
What could undermine it: Wrong circuit information, another supply, ineffective isolation or someone restoring power without agreement.
Depends on: Competent electrical support is available; Circuit and lamp information is reliable; There is time and authority to stop
Let the lamp cool before handling
In everyday language: Allow a previously lit lamp to cool sufficiently before anyone handles it, using the fitting and lamp manufacturer's guidance.
Why it belongs here: Removing the unexpected heat reduces the chance of a painful startle and loss of balance. It does not make the electrical supply safe.
What to check: Plan cooling time and confirm the lamp can be handled safely; do not reach up to test a hot surface with a bare hand.
Owner: The task planner and the person doing the work.
What could undermine it: Rushing, an incorrect assumption about temperature or another person switching it on again.
Depends on: Circuit and lamp information is reliable; There is time and authority to stop
Suitable platform guardrails limit a fall
In everyday language: If the person loses balance inside a suitable guarded platform, its edge protection can prevent a fall over the edge and limit the resulting harm.
Why it belongs here: The guardrails are installed before the task, but their recovery function is called on after balance is lost. They cannot be assumed to work if the whole platform tips or collapses.
What to check: Use complete, suitable edge protection and the correct gate or entrance arrangement. Check the manufacturer's setup and never stand on, climb over or lean beyond the rails. This is not a suggestion to add improvised rails to steps.
Owner: The equipment owner and competent user.
What could undermine it: Missing rails, an open gate, unsuitable dimensions, or the same unstable support that defeats the access control.
Depends on: Suitable access equipment is actually available; The supporting floor remains sound and level; People know the limits of the task
Keep other people out of the landing area
In everyday language: The work area remains clear so a falling person or lamp is less likely to strike someone below.
Why it belongs here: This limits exposure of other people after balance is lost. It does not prevent the worker's own fall. The same area arrangement also helps prevent people striking the access on the left.
What to check: Maintain the exclusion area for the whole task, including handling the removed lamp. If it cannot be maintained, pause and replan.
Owner: The task lead and the person coordinating the room.
What could undermine it: People bypass the area, a route reopens, or the space is too small to protect others.
Depends on: Other people and doors are managed; There is time and authority to stop
Use planned emergency and first-aid arrangements
In everyday language: People know how to raise the alarm, summon suitable help and respond without creating another casualty.
Why it belongs here: Prompt appropriate help can limit worsening injury. It does not stop the loss of balance, prevent every injury or justify unsafe access.
What to check: Agree a proportionate emergency plan, usable communication, location information and suitable competent help before work. Consider any equipment-specific rescue needs. Do not rely solely on an unplanned emergency-service rescue.
Owner: The task lead and the workplace emergency coordinator.
What could undermine it: No usable phone or contact route, lone work without arrangements, missing capability or an unpractised plan.
Depends on: The emergency response can actually work; People know the limits of the task; There is time and authority to stop
The worker suffers impact injuries
In everyday language: A fall onto the floor or furniture can cause fractures, a serious head injury or death, even on a task that felt routine.
Why it belongs here: This is a harmful outcome after loss of balance or support. It is not the hazard or the top event.
What to check: Prioritise avoiding raised access and preventing loss of control. Do not rely on first aid, a low score or the presence of a diagram to make a fall acceptable.
Someone below is struck and injured
In everyday language: A falling person or dropped lamp can strike another person, causing impact injury or cuts.
Why it belongs here: The task can harm someone who is not changing the bulb. A lamp dropped without any loss of balance would be a separate event pathway.
What to check: Keep others clear, control loose materials and assess separate falling-object and glass hazards for the actual lamp and fitting.
An injury becomes worse while help is delayed
In everyday language: An injured person may wait without appropriate assistance, or an improvised rescue may expose someone else to harm.
Why it belongs here: Emergency arrangements address what happens after things have gone wrong. They support prevention rather than replace it.
What to check: Make sure the agreed response is realistic for the workplace, people, access equipment and means of communication.
People know the limits of the task
In everyday language: The planner and user can select and check the method, recognise a change and stop when the work exceeds their competence.
Why it belongs here: Several controls rely on the same judgement. Repeating the same instruction or collecting two signatures does not create independent barriers.
What to check: Match demonstrated knowledge and experience to this task and equipment; provide suitable supervision and specialist support where needed.
Owner: The person assigning and supervising the work.
What could undermine it: Training on different equipment, unfamiliar conditions or no route to competent advice.
Suitable access equipment is actually available
In everyday language: The planned platform and its safety features are available, fit the room and suit the working position and task.
Why it belongs here: Both stable access and the recovery guardrails depend on the same equipment. They are different functions, not two wholly independent systems.
What to check: Check availability, size, condition and manufacturer limits before scheduling the task. If suitable access is absent, postpone or choose a safer method.
Owner: The task planner and equipment owner.
What could undermine it: The platform is in use elsewhere, too large for the room, damaged or substituted with furniture.
The supporting floor remains sound and level
In everyday language: The floor can support the chosen equipment and is free from conditions that could make it slip, tilt or move.
Why it belongs here: A floor or support failure can defeat stable access and its guardrails together. Counting both as independent protection would be misleading.
What to check: Inspect the actual setup location and resolve water, loose surfaces, unevenness or uncertain support before use.
Owner: The competent user and person controlling the room.
What could undermine it: A spill, damaged floor, loose mat or moving the equipment without reassessing its position.
Other people and doors are managed
In everyday language: Room users understand the arrangements and safe routes remain available while the work area is protected.
Why it belongs here: One coordinated exclusion arrangement can both protect the access and keep others out of a falling-object area. It is one shared arrangement with two functions.
What to check: Agree who maintains the area, how doors are controlled and when normal use resumes. Preserve emergency escape.
Owner: The task lead and room manager.
What could undermine it: Unbriefed occupants, an unstaffed temporary arrangement or pressure to reopen the route.
Competent electrical support is available
In everyday language: Someone with appropriate electrical competence can establish and verify the safe condition and control reinstatement.
Why it belongs here: A person who can change a bulb is not automatically competent to isolate, test or repair an installation.
What to check: Know who provides the electrical safety decision. If the fitting is damaged, unfamiliar or outside the agreed task, stop and refer it.
Owner: The person controlling the electrical work.
What could undermine it: No competent help, unclear responsibility or treating a wall switch as an isolation test.
Circuit and lamp information is reliable
In everyday language: The team has correct information about the fitting, lamp, electrical supplies and manufacturer's limits.
Why it belongs here: An incorrect circuit label or wrong lamp assumption can undermine otherwise careful actions.
What to check: Resolve uncertainty before starting; consider other feeds and use competent verification rather than trusting a label alone.
Owner: The facilities manager and competent electrical person.
What could undermine it: Outdated labels, undocumented alterations, missing instructions or an incompatible replacement lamp.
There is time and authority to stop
In everyday language: The job can wait for cooling, safe access, isolation, a clear room and competent support. People can stop without pressure to improvise.
Why it belongs here: Rushing can weaken several different controls at once. Five boxes on a bowtie are not five independent protections if all depend on the same rushed decision.
What to check: Plan the resources and safe working window. Resolve missing prerequisites before a separate responsible decision to proceed.
Owner: The manager scheduling and authorising the task.
What could undermine it: A deadline, a busy room, unavailable equipment or a message to get it done regardless.
The emergency response can actually work
In everyday language: Usable communication and the planned competent assistance are available in this location at this time.
Why it belongs here: A telephone number written on a form is not the same as a workable response.
What to check: Confirm contact, location information, access for help and any planned equipment-specific rescue capability before work.
Owner: The task lead and emergency coordinator.
What could undermine it: No signal, an inaccessible room, absent first-aid support or a plan nobody understands.